Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by air on Monday December 23, 2013 @05:44PM
(#6957063)
User using multiple applications on a single phone is quite a lot more common use case than user using single application on several phones. I'd opt for making the common use case consistent.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by poolpool on Monday December 23, 2013 @05:38PM
(#6957024)
So you prefer an objectively worse experience across all two serious platforms in case you switch?
How often are you jumping between iOS and android that this is an actual, real concern?
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Touche on Monday December 23, 2013 @06:17PM
(#6957243)
I disagree that all web apps are "objectively worse". I use HackerWeb[1] because I believe it to be better than any of the Android apps I've tried..
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by girvo on Monday December 23, 2013 @09:51PM
(#6957977)
To be perfectly fair, HackerWeb is the best web application I'm terms of cross platform performance I have ever ever seen.
Edit, wait oops I thought you meant http://hn.premii.com but HackerWeb is well done too!
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Touche on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @09:36AM
(#6959479)
"To be perfectly fair" implies that it shouldn't count. Does the Premii app demonstrate what can be done given the effort?
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by girvo on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:59AM
(#6962444)
To achieve those results requires a lot of effort, and hardcore optimisation. Native coding gets you the same results, minus all that effort (as long as you're okay with targeting one platform), so yeah I was sort of saying it doesn't count IMO :)
That said, I'm building all my applications using web tools, Facebooks React allows for some amazing native performance, cross platform! If the views are decoupled enough, you can get two UIs with the exact same logic client and server side, with near native performance to boot.
Now it's not there yet, but it's super close, and once tooling is built up to tackle this use case with the new tech and architecture (client side), then I think it'll be a very big deal!
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by gobengo on Monday December 23, 2013 @05:40PM
(#6957033)
It seems to me that switching phones is .0001% of the user experience. Loading the app, tapping things to switch views quickly, etc is the vast majority.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Touche on Monday December 23, 2013 @06:01PM
(#6957173)
Of course, many users don't think about lock-in until they buy a Roku and discover all those movies they bought on iTunes won't play on it, but I think about it every single time I install an app. That's why I prefer apps that don't burden me with the worry.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Tloewald on Monday December 23, 2013 @05:33PM
(#6956993)
So, as a user, you don't change phones to one that forces you to do without your favorite apps, learn a new UI, and so on.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Touche on Monday December 23, 2013 @05:39PM
(#6957029)
The fact that I need to worry about this at all is a bad user experience.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by Tloewald on Monday December 23, 2013 @07:00PM
(#6957402)
Because you expect to buy any product at any price and for everything to Just Work — fantasy.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by benburton on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:32PM
(#6958086)
You must have a really tough time renting cars.
Re:I used Firefox OS for 30 days and it made me want to quit...
by erichocean on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @04:08PM
(#6961134)
Or using remote controls.
I strongly disagree with your definition of "user experience". I believe that changing phones and having to install different apps, with different UIs, or possibly doing without one because the new phone doesn't have an equivalent, is a bad user experience.
This is my opinion as a user, not as a developer.