The "gouging" has three big effects: (1) More drivers willing to deal with the weather for the increased pay, so more people can get out of the storm; (2) A (highly imperfect) way to prioritize the people who most want/need the service. A person who really, really, really needs to move quickly has a way to credibly express that preference over someone who would kind of like an Uber, but could do without - by being willing to pay the higher rate. (3), or course, is more money for Uber. (1) and (2) are very good things, and I'm indifferent to (3).
"Gouging" is generally only a thing when there's a monopoly, which Uber doesn't have on transportation. People can look up Uber rates and decide if it's still worth it to them to go Uber or take something else.
(See http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/wonkblog/wp/2013/12/20/u...)
Uber's approach solved both problems: filter down the list of ride requests to those who really need to go, and provide an incentive for drivers to drive during the really nasty weather.
Uber is a luxury good, and the price floats with supply/demand. There's nothing wrong with that, and no one is entitled to use their service.
Whether or not you call it gouging mostly has to do with how essential a service you consider transportation to be.
As noted elsewhere in this thread, the alternative is a shortage—that is, not being able to acquire it for any price. Wanting to make a good or service unavailable to anyone at any price is... odd.
See http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2007/01/munger_on_price_1.h... for more.
Laws against price gouging are almost always against the public interest.
The alternative is no drivers on the road, so the increased demand pricing probably comes out on top in terms of number of rides completed.
Also, it's not an overall shortage. Take San Francisco for example: there are lots of public transportation options, yellow cabs, and Uber clones, forgetting walking or bicycles. What's in shortage? Only Uber.
In the meanwhile, price is the way the rest of the world works.
It's the fact that Uber profits from misfortune (not surge pricing itself) that is making everyone hate them.
Ultimately it's about trade-offs, not absolutes. Is that 5x price hike saving me (compared to how long getting a cab would take) two hours, or 20 seconds? That would be worth knowing. If it's 2 hours, the supply-and-demand argument makes sense: apparently, that's how high the rates must go to compensate drivers for the unpleasantness. If it's 20 seconds, then that's a case of me getting screwed for a minor convenience priced unreasonably.
Wow, you must be REALLY fun to stand behind in line at the coffee shop. "WADDYA MEAN $3 FOR THIS COFFEE? I COULD HAVE MADE IT FOR 10 CENTS! WHY ARE YOU SCREWING ME?"
For reference, "getting screwed" would be what was happening if surge pricing was applied when you got out of the cab without your knowledge - not a advertised-up-front price that you don't agree with.
Given that you don't believe in the principle of supply and demand (or you think it is extremely lazy, as you said). How would you balance demand with supply in extreme situations? What is the non-lazy solution? I guess we could try:
* Force more drivers to drive at the normal price to match demand (the totalitarian approach)
* Ensure that there are enough drivers to meet peak demand through subsidies to get them through normal demand times.
What else am I missing here?
Lots of other businesses operate the same way.