News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by mcenedella on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:16AM (#6954633)
The correct title for the map is “Countries where employers are fined or threatened with jail time for not providing maternity leave”.

Despite what our ‘enlightened’ friends the world over think about the dark, backwards, USA, it is not, in fact, illegal to provide paid maternity leave in the US.

This map, and the comments in this thread, support mandatory, government-backed maternity leave in the amount and style which the government believes is appropriate. Honest differences in preferences or opinions are subject to government punishment.

In the USA, we are skeptical of the benefits of the government making it a law to do mothering the way the government wants you to. We ask “Why is it noble to force people to forgo higher wages and other benefits for an in-kind contribution to a particular type of maternal care?”

The argument against government-mandated benefits has been made elsewhere in great detail. Facts, evidence, history, and common sense indicate that forcing people to consume their wages the way the government wants, in the the style the government wants, decreases the success of the overall community. That’s why every people who has ever had the chance to overthrow communism, has. And that’s why the children of all these states in Europe find that jobs are very difficult to get, and many of them, particularly the entrepreneurial ones, come to America.

Fewer rules imposed on people lead to greater growth, which leads to greater health, happiness, wealth, and longevity.

Further, there is something immoral about threatening to throw people in jail, or fine them, if they don’t do exactly what the government says on something as basic as raising your children.

To those who say that we should go ahead and follow “The Man” and be happy for these gifts, you have to realize that we are paying for the benefits, not the government, so forcing us to do it the way “they” want it, in a one-size-fits-all manner is not really a benefit to anybody.

You may say that it is only fair, or right, or just, that there be 3 months, or 12 months, or 24 months of paid maternity leave. 24/7/365 child care is bliss for many mothers — perhaps most. But for others, they may prefer to spend those dollars on better daycare, or weeklong breaks interspersed with work, or a 4-day week, or they may be just fine with working a full week and spending a more focused, quality time with their child on their days off.

Demanding that one size fits all, that the government has figured out the correct style of maternal care once and for all time, (when, it should be noted, every government legislature in the world is still majority male), and that those who disagree should be fined or thrown in jail, is not, in fact, a kind or compassionate policy, but a kind of abuse.

Incorrectly titled maps may be great for click bait, but they shouldn’t pass for deep analysis here on HackerNews.

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by posabsolute on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:30AM (#6954707)
Your wrong on how maternity leaves work, at least in Canada. Employers do not pay for the maternity, they just can't fire you (& you don't have to take the leave, lol like they force you to do that...)

It's the society (government) that pays for leaves. In canada it looks like this: the parental benefit is 7 weeks at 70%, followed by 25 weeks at 55% from salary on a maximum of 50-60k salary

For me what you say is backwards, but I guess you are right, there is clearly no gain in life for a mother to take the time she need to adapt & connect with her children for a year.

Then again it is the poors that suffer that cannot in anyway take some time off from work. Or maybe it is the argument that you should not pay for others.

I guess you can keep being skeptical

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by TruthElixirX on Monday December 23, 2013 @12:39PM (#6955421)
>It's the society (government) that pays for leaves.

So the companies in Canada don't pay taxes? Sign me up!

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by a3n on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:53PM (#6955869)
Like most decisions that society makes as a group, the cost is spread over most of the group, over time, so that more people can benefit from the policy. It's the very nature of how government works. Yes, because it costs everyone, such policies should be given close scrutiny. But merely being paid by everyone through taxes is not reason enough to condemn a policy; the logical conclusion to that is no government at all, which comes with its own costs and benefits.
Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by marquis on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:21AM (#6954654)
>Demanding that one size fits all, that the government has figured out the correct style of maternal care once and for all time

The countries mandated by legislation do not force parents to take leave. As you say, many parents prefer to work part time or scatter time across a period of months/years. Legislation affords worker rights, as much as legislating fair working conditions in general is a benefit to workers. Can you give me an example of a country with a free market where workers and employers get along without legislation?

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by tbrownaw on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:26AM (#6954681)
The countries mandated by legislation do not force parents to take leave

They force parents (as well as people who choose not to become parents) to pay for that leave whether they take it or not.

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by marquis on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:36AM (#6954741)
I'm not a parent. But goddamn if I don't want parents to give their children the best possible early childhood that is available. If that costs me 30% of my salary, so that our society is healthy, educated, safe, well-balanced I'll pay it. Anyone who can't see that without an excellent early childhood plan in place our society is doomed is living with their head in the sand. I don't understand the vitriol on this website for parents and that legislating so that they have a chance is somehow socialist evil.
Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by bryanlarsen on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:40AM (#6954764)
That leave is paid back several times over. A skilled work force is the greatest asset any country has. The first few years of life are the most important; spending money on a child for the first few years of it's life should result in significantly increased benefit to society throughout their later working life.
Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by yummyfajitas on Monday December 23, 2013 @11:16AM (#6954971)
It's hardly clear that this is true. The most recent study I've seen suggests it is actually a waste of money.

http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2348505

Do you have any info suggesting otherwise?

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by ceautery on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:29AM (#6954701)
"In the USA, we are skeptical of the benefits of the government making it a law to do mothering the way the government wants you to."

What an ignorant statement. Maternity and paternity leave are about requiring employers to allow you early bonding time with your children, not about the nanny state judging how you parent.

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by kyrra on Monday December 23, 2013 @11:05AM (#6954909)
True conservative think wants to keep the government out of things and let companies decide things, as companies can switch policies at a much faster pace than the government.

What is thought as "good parenting" keep switching. If you look at child birth and newborn care in the US over the last 100 years, you will find a lot of different things that have been done.

The current trends are pushing for moms and dads to get as much bonding as possible right from the start. I think this is a great idea and really should be a standard.

Also, the US does require employers to give employees 12 weeks of unpaid leave (without threat of firing) for large family events (from the FMLA law). It's not perfect, but at least it's something.

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by rayiner on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:25PM (#6956029)
> Fewer rules imposed on people lead to greater growth, which leads to greater health, happiness, wealth, and longevity.

This is easy to discredit. We have rules that prevent us from clubbing each other on the head and taking what we can from the corpse. By your reasoning, getting rid of this rule would increase growth and lead to greater prosperity. But most people would disagree.

This sort of reasoning is always code for "my favored set of rules is better."

Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by mdellabitta on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:39AM (#6954759)
It should be said that this poster does not speak for all Americans, and not even a majority of them.
Re:Paid maternity leave world maps for mothers and fathers by r3m6 on Monday December 23, 2013 @10:37AM (#6954752)
Youth unemployment is currently a serious problems in a few European states (e. g. Spain) but (a) not in most and (b) it is certainly not related to maternity leave or universal health insurance.