News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by morgante on Monday December 23, 2013 @12:44AM (#6953238)
This is why nobody should ever use a debit card... just get credit cards.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by valleyer on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:15AM (#6953315)
Huh? What's to stop them from doing this to credit cards?

Edit: To clarify, I understood the parent comment to mean that this lowering of limits was why I should use credit cards over debit cards.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by cynwoody on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:04AM (#6953410)
Nothing.

The difference is that, when fraudsters hit your credit card, you're not out any money, ab initio. You call the card company and make them take the fraudulent charge off your bill. If they refuse, they have to sue to get your money. But if the bad boys nail your debit card, your account is dinged immediately, and you have to deal with the bank to get your funds restored.

Therefore, you should use ATM cards at ATMs only and only use credit cards to shop and travel and dine out (and enjoy the float and the points and pay in full every month). If your ATM card has a credit card logo (called a "check card"), call your bank and complain, and they'll issue you one that is only an ATM card and cannot be used to shop without a PIN.

It's worth noting that the Target case is confined to credit cards, not debit cards. To hack a debit card, the attacker must intercept both the mag stripes and the PIN that goes with them. That's hard to do, given the way PIN pads work. Reportedly, in the Target case, they did not succeed in doing that.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by rm999 on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:42AM (#6953485)
There are a few inaccuracies in your comment.

>If they refuse, they have to sue to get your money

First, they wouldn't refuse (at least in the USA) because Visa and Mastercard contractually require issuers to cover debit cards at the same level as they do for credit cards, which is complete protection from all liability.

Second, with credit cards you can't just decide what to pay off and what not to. If the issuer refuses fraud protection to you for whatever reason your credit rating is on the line if you don't pay off the balance. They may sue you, and they may damage your ability to get credit for a long time.

In other words, the situation between debit and credit card protection is basically the same: in both cases the issuer will almost certainly protect you, and you're screwed if they don't.

> To hack a debit card, the attacker must intercept both the mag stripes and the PIN that goes with them.

This is not true in the USA. Debit cards can be used in non-point of sale transactions (e.g. phone or internet) and point of sale non-PIN "signature" transactions where you use your debit card like a credit card.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by cynwoody on Monday December 23, 2013 @12:39PM (#6955424)
>Debit cards can be used in non-point of sale transactions (e.g. phone or internet) and point of sale non-PIN "signature" transactions where you use your debit card like a credit card.

That's true of most debit cards, namely the ones that sport a Visa or MasterCard logo. They are called "check cards" and can be used in either debit mode (enter PIN on PINpad, no signature) or credit mode (sign if over the merchant-defined limit). Either way, the charge goes against your bank account as soon as the bank receives it.

The difference between credit and debit mode is in who processes the charge. For PIN-less signature mode, the credit card network handles the transaction. For PIN debit mode, the debit network (e.g. NYCE) handles it. The debit networks are immediate: the money comes right out of your account. The credit card networks are slower. It may take a day or two for a transaction to hit your account.

I remember fifteen or twenty years ago when my bank introduced check cards. I called them and asked if the new MC logo meant the card could be used without entering a PIN. They said yes, and I said I didn't want it. A replacement minus the logo (and with a different PAN) arrived a day or two later.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by dingaling on Monday December 23, 2013 @03:42AM (#6953610)
> To hack a debit card, the attacker must intercept both the mag stripes and the PIN that goes with them

As a naive non-credit-card-European I used my debit card in a Chicagoland Target a couple of years ago. There was no chip-reader, so the clerk took my card and swiped it for me, with a scathing glower.

I stood and waited for something to sign - nope. That was it, payment accepted. I was rather shocked.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by zevyoura on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:19AM (#6953325)
It's not that they couldn't do it to credit cards, but credit cards generally have better consumer fraud protections than debit cards.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by w4 on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:20AM (#6953327)
You can easily reverse the charges on credit cards, unlike (usually, though not in this case per the banks' statements) debit cards.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by gwillen on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:23AM (#6953337)
Debit cards with a Visa or Mastercard logo have the same protections as credit cards, by contract (though unlike credit cards not by law), when used for non-PIN transactions.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by jedbrown on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:01AM (#6953405)
The difference is that between the time of the fraudulent charge and its resolution, your money is not in your account. With a credit card, it never makes it that far.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by gnur on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:54AM (#6953520)
In the US perhaps, in the Netherlands (and the most of Europe) debit cards are the only card used in daily transactions. Credit Cards are becoming more common now and I think the main reason for that is transactions with the US. The only reason I have a credit card is for easier online shopping, even though we have a really good system for online shopping with debit cards (iDeal). But to use iDeal you need your debit card + PIN + device (with my bank anyway) to make a transaction, with a credit card you can just remember everything to make a transaction.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by bowlofpetunias on Monday December 23, 2013 @03:15AM (#6953563)
Add to that the fact that the hackable magnetic strip is totally history here, and in the vast majority of transactions, both physical and online, the merchant doesn't get any relevant data.

I'm sure someone at some point will hack the chip, but right now you can safely lose your physical debit card, and you don't have to worry about leaks and hacks at merchants.

Credit cards with their totally outdated zero authentication methods and that allow the merchant to store all the data necessary to use the account without even physically having that card are the ones that are completely unsafe.

It's ridiculous that this system is still in use. Using credit cards instead of debit cards is really, really bad advice for anybody outside the US.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by dsaber on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:42AM (#6953487)
Debit cards can't be used without a PIN number, right? Target indicates that there is no evidence PIN numbers were compromised, so even if the cards got stolen, they're not that useful without brute-forcing the PIN. As such, I would think credit cards are more valuable to thieves.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by Crito on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:59AM (#6953530)
You don't need to really brute force the pins.

What you do is you a separate list of known pins and work out the most likely pin is. Then you assume that all of your new Debit cards have that pin. Most won't have that pin, but for many of them you'll now have a working pin. For those you did not ever enter a wrong pin, so any sort of brute-force attempt detection software will never have any reason to suspect a thing.

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by bilalq on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:44AM (#6953489)
You can use a debit card as a credit card in most cases though. If you hit cancel on the PIN prompt, it gives you the option to sign and charge as credit.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by dsaber on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:48AM (#6953499)
True, however my understanding is that, by contract, debit cards via Visa/Mastercard have the same protections as credit cards. So consumers can submit claims against fraudulent transactions the same way they would via a credit card.
Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by pyre on Monday December 23, 2013 @03:01AM (#6953536)
The difference is that since they are backed by your bank account (rather than a running balance that you owe the credit card company or bank), the money comes directly out of your bank account. Depending on your bank's policies, even an immediate refund (with no fraud involved) might take a couple of weeks to credit back to your account. So, sure you might be made whole again in the end, but you are still out the cash in the meantime.

That may or may not matter to you depending on your financial situation, but it's probably much better to be in a position where you are debating/challenging what you owe rather than what someone else owes you.

Note: I know that the mechanics are slightly different when you "run it as a credit card" rather than a debit card, but you may be in the same boat if the money has already left your bank account (unless Visa or MasterCard lean on the bank to make things go faster in such situations).

Re:Millions of Target shoppers face new debit card limits by code_duck on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:56AM (#6953525)
Rather than losing credit against your credit limit, however, while awaiting resolution by your bank one would be out actual cash. Credit card companies act like actual cash is more valuable than credit - lower cash withdrawal limits, higher interest - and I'd agree.