I agree with you. But I can agree with what you're saying and still be repelled by the logic of stealing nonessential goods that are being sold on what we think are unreasonable terms.
The real losers of the battle are the artists, not the labels (they still make plenty) or the freeloaders.
That this is obviously true has, I'm sure you can see, no bearing on the original argument.
The artists are losing, just as they have always done. However now at least cracks are appearing in the production/marketing/distribution oligopoly, with the potential a new model, fairer to the artists, will arise in their place.
The long term loser of this war will be the labels, and good riddance.
I agree about the rationalization (dressed up as morality) on both sides of this. Still, the conclusion that seems inevitable is: if enough people do it, it isn't stealing.
Not to be a complete relativist, but it's naive to believe that the way we formulate moral rules (e.g. how we define stealing) isn't historically conditioned. This is a moment when that's visible because conditions are changing faster than our rules. The rules will have to change. As with all such changes, some entrenched interests will lose. That the record industry turns out to be the loser this time is, for anyone who knows how they've comported themselves in the past, a feature not a bug. (Yeah I know I'm repeating myself and that the latter bit is irrelevant to your point, but on this subject I can't help it: the karmic comeuppance is just too tasty.)
The spectacle of the music industry portraying itself as "good" and music fans as "evil" is a great comic irony of our time.