News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by tptacek on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:20PM (#6951801)
The same people who get angry when one suggests that throwing a brick through the back of a bus window might not be an action at ethical par with voting or circulating a petition. Try skimming the comment histories of the people who seem most invested in these stories. They're illuminating.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by dannypgh on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:48PM (#6951920)
I find your closed mindedness disturbing. I have tons more sympathy towards people struggling against gentrification, however they believe is appropriate, than overprivileged silicon valley employees who believe the world is anything approaching a meritocracy.

You and others can believe that those of us who feel this way are noncontributing leeches or don't belong here or what have you, but I am a Google engineer who works hard in this industry. There are things that are downright unfair in this world and the continuous displacement of peoples, many of whom have had little opportunity and faced constant oppression, ranks high among them in my book.

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by tptacek on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:01PM (#6951971)
Another signpost characteristic of the kinds of people who vote these stories up: the belief that someone who says it's wrong to throw bricks through the backs of bus windows must also believe that "gentrification" and displacement are good things, or that lower-income people are "non-contributing leeches". The people throwing bricks might be leeches, but what makes them all the worse is the disservice they do to a legitimate cause.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by ChrisNorstrom on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:56PM (#6951949)
Yes it's sad. But what are the options? Are you saying neighborhoods should never increase in property value? People complain when wealthier residents "invade" a poor neighborhood and lower the crime rate and raise the property values but no one says anything when poorer residents move into a neighborhood and increase the crime and lower the property value. And there are a LOT of cities like that. In St. Louis alone: South St. Louis, Spanish lake, Bellfontaine, Ferguson, Dellwood, Maryland Heights, Black Jack, Hazelwood have all had this happen to them.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by HarryHirsch on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:13PM (#6952006)
Is it true that no one says anything when poorer residents move in? In general, suburban America is very good at keeping poverty out, it plays out every time when public transport or affordable housing is suggested to be built somewhere.

The next thing that would need to happen is that the police department gets extra funding because the two suburban cops currently there have neither the manpower nor the expertise to deal with the increase in crime.

The locals tend to vote against either, and who can blame them? It's the system that's at fault, especially the fact that a substantial amount of taxes is raised and spent locally.

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by HarryHirsch on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:43PM (#6951899)
This is going to be downvoted, but it needs to be said: voting and petitioning is part of the political process, but so is participating in politics as an elected or unelected official.

Being a politician gives you an entirely different set of powers, because you get to decide what people get to vote on. You can put facts on the ground. "Direct action" also puts facts on the ground and gives some balance to the political process.

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by tptacek on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:11PM (#6951999)
I don't know what you're trying to say here because you use a term, "direct action", that means different things to different people. The people I know personally who are involved in labor politics use the term "direct action" to refer to sit-ins and picket lines. But hobbyist black bloc forums use the term as a euphemism for throwing bricks through glass.

So let's be specific: did the comment you just write try to communicate your belief that throwing a brick through the back of a bus full of people "puts facts on the ground" and "gives some balance" to the process?

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by mgunes on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:22PM (#6951806)
I'm one of those people: I submit that throwing a brick through the back of a bus window is ethically superior to voting or circulating a petition. Please skim my comment history.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by raldi on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:03PM (#6951978)
I'm curious about the rest of your moral framework. How would you sort the following list, in order of increasing ethical superiority?

Voting

Circulating a petition

Doing nothing

Throwing a brick through a bus window

Sending death threats

Spraypainting "[ethnicity] GO HOME" on someone's house

Leaving a burning cross on their lawn

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by kika on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:08PM (#6951988)
Hm, what about lynching a couple of Google engineers? Ethically superior or inferior? If inferior, then why? I'm actually genuinely interested though may sound sarcastic - I'm very curious where people like you draw the line between "good" violence and "bad" violence.
Re:Where No Google Buses Go by keithpeter on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:53PM (#6951941)
I did have a look at your submission history, thanks, some nice reading there.

Quote from OA

"...one in ten mortgages was foreclosed in San Pablo. At the same time San Francisco’s rate of foreclosure was a mere 2 percent."

Those rates are huge! At the worst of the recession, we hit about one per 300 in the UK, and that was considered bad enough for urgent action to support arrears and find ways for people to restructure their debt.

Re:Where No Google Buses Go by walshemj on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:06PM (#6951984)
The BNP in the UK and golden dawn in Greece also believe in direct violent action against the minorities they disprove of so thats ok then?