News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by rictic on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:50PM (#6951686)
This post fills me with questions. Foremost: What makes anti-aging technology unnatural compared to other medical treatments? To take one example, the smallpox vaccine was initially considered unnatural, and an affront to God[1].

[1] http://abob.libs.uga.edu/bobk/whitem10.html

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by wpietri on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:03PM (#6951725)
I think it's fair to call most medical treatments unnatural. That doesn't make them bad, but it should make us thoughtful and careful. Natural systems are often, thanks to evolution and adaptation, complicated and delicately balanced.

I think reflexive appeals to tradition and novelty are both kind of dumb. But if people are going to err, I'd rather they erred on the side of tradition: at least that shit has been demonstrated to work in one fashion or another. I always try to keep in mind examples like Eben Byers [1], the THERAC 25 [2], and rabbits in Australia [3]. All sorts of stupid ideas look appealing at first.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eben_Byers

[2] http://courses.cs.vt.edu/cs3604/lib/Therac_25/Therac_1.html

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rabbits_in_Australia#Effects_on...

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by chc on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:22PM (#6951807)
Eben Byers was a victim of quack medicine, much like people nowadays who try to use magnets and sugar water to cure cancer. Bringing him up in a discussion of real medicine is frankly an insult to the researchers who do this stuff.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by wpietri on Monday December 23, 2013 @12:07AM (#6953172)
Once you're done stroking your outrage gland, you might note that I didn't suggest an equivalence between these researchers and, well, anybody. I was talking about ideas made appealing by ignorance, ones that are dumb only in retrospect.

The patent medicine Byers took was legal. Indeed his doctor recommended it to him. Unsurprising given that its seller, William J. A. Bailey, offered doctors a 17% kickback to prescribe the stuff. Even after this product was banned (because it finally killed a rich guy?), Bailey was never prosecuted, and continued to sell radium-related products after this. He died wealthy and free at the age of 64, nearly 14 years after killing Byers, and who knows how many other people.

It's a fine example of what I was talking about, where erring on the side of the shiny and new was not a good heuristic; the people who stuck with the traditional and natural did better for themselves despite Bailey and Byers surely scoffing at them.

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by itchitawa on Sunday December 22, 2013 @08:48PM (#6952642)
One of the Therac-25 victims died 3 months later from cancer. Presumably the same cancer they were trying to treat, and thus avoided needing a hip replacement for the radiation damage. If your life is in such extreme danger from the disease itself, it can be worth taking risks with novel treatments. I'm sure some very old people with nothing to lose will be willing to try anti-aging, no matter how risky.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by wpietri on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @08:09PM (#6961807)
The supposedly good idea I'm referring to for the Therac-25 isn't radiation therapy. It was using software to make something snazzily digital, but in a way that ignored the novel safety issues with digital devices.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by 31reasons on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:23AM (#6953338)
With your attitude I don't think we would ever invent or discover any medicine or treatment. Agreed, natural systems are complicated and delicately balanced, but we have Physics, Math, Chemistry and Computer Science to help us understand those delicately balanced and complicated systems. Please give some credit to Human Intelligence that itself is a product of millions of years of evolution. I often hear people saying "X can't be done because evolution perfected it". I call it bullshit. Evolutionary systems are not perfect and can be improved with right tools and we do have the tools.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by wpietri on Monday December 23, 2013 @09:39PM (#6957945)
You seem to be arguing with a bunch of things I didn't say, while ignoring the things I did.

I'm a giant fan of technology, and there are many amazing advances in medical tech. But I'm not a fan of thoughtless adoption of something just because it a) sounds good and b) is shiny and new.

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by Udo on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:18PM (#6951787)
Sorry, I fat-fingered on the downvote button with my iDevice, I meant to vote you up (because of the first paragraph specifically, not so much the rest).

Could someone counteract me, please?

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by pfortuny on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:23PM (#6951810)
Done.... Just you make a little sport in my stead and get a thinner thumb will you?

Just kidding.

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by Udo on Sunday December 22, 2013 @04:29PM (#6951843)
Thanks!

Maybe I'll consider thumb-thinning surgery instead ;)

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by crgt on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:41PM (#6952301)
Sounds unnatural.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by kbenson on Monday December 23, 2013 @03:33AM (#6953590)
That's a nice way to get at least a few upvotes for them, since I doubt you'll get just one taker.
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by VLM on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:33PM (#6952076)
Wouldn't this treatment system create an immense selection pressure against irrational belief?

So kids born to families who think its an affront to god would not have the social / cultural / monetary resources to even begin to compete with kids born to more rational families?

Not that I'm saying a selection pressure against irrational belief would be a negative or a problem, I'm just saying it would be strongly selected against?

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by acgourley on Monday December 23, 2013 @02:24AM (#6953447)
Only if people who take this anti-aging have more offspring. It's quite possible the opposite would be true.. "oh there is no rush, maybe next decade"
Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by VLM on Monday December 23, 2013 @09:08AM (#6954261)
I was thinking more in terms of reproductive success of kids who have enormous very old and presumably wise family members to act as mentors and advisors.

I had a grandfather who rose to pretty high levels in the Army and executive level in a major national railroad, he could provide some advice about management. A G-Grandfather who was a good enough CPA to never end up unemployed in the great depression, he presumably could teach me a thing or two about accounting. A grandpa-in-law who was a successful combat medic, after treating combat injuries normal lifestyle trauma would make him handy to have around (edited to add, patching up blown off limbs made him a peace activist type in his later years, another good reason to keep him around). One of my grandma was one of those flapper / womens suffrage / womens lib radical types and she'd be a good influence on my daughter. If we extend life over 200 years, I have a Harvard lit prof in my ancestry who would be a handy tutor for my kids, and a civil war era land surveyor who could probably teach even me a thing or two about wilderness hiking and survival, etc.

If you do enough genealogy, everyone's got enough "cool" in their ancestry, that if those ancestors were still alive, kids lifestyle would be radically improved compared to folks with dead ancestors.

Of course human nature being what it is, the 10% of cool would come with 90% of hatred, bigotry, ignorance, blah blah, so you'd have to take it all with a grain of salt. (edited to add, and learning the critical thinking skills to take it all with a grain of salt, would overall be one of the most valuable skills...)

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by api on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:22PM (#6952232)
"To take one example, the smallpox vaccine was initially considered unnatural, and an affront to God[1]."

In hell, conservatives will have the ability to turn off the flames.

Re:Anti-ageing compound set for human trials after turning c... by sytelus on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @03:01AM (#6958672)
If something can be done, it can't be "unnatural". Unnatural things or processes DO NOT exists by definition.