News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by InclinedPlane on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:46PM (#6944621)
I disagree with many of tptacek's opinions but honestly he's one of the reasons this site is great. He is capable of arguing with people with strongly opposing views with civility, which is something that is entirely too rare these days. He's also capable of admitting when he's wrong and being gracious when proven right. Also entirely too rare these days. I'd rather have a thousand tptaceks on this site than zero.
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by bane on Friday December 20, 2013 @06:10PM (#6944747)
> He is capable of arguing with people with strongly opposing views with civility

You're clearly talking about a different tptacek, widely known on this site for his coarsely abrasive, impossibly high friction, social interactions and not admitting he's wrong on issues trivial or important. He's also widely known for a being an expert in his field.

All that being said, I agree with you that this site is more valuable with him on it and regularly participating. He's one of the actual experts in their field that makes this a much better forum than any other. IMHO, it's well worth the comment burn to talk and debate (friendly or not) with somebody of his caliber.

And being wrong every once in a while (regardless of his rightness in this case) does not make him either incompetent or malicious. It just makes him human.

Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by sillysaurus2 on Saturday December 21, 2013 @06:10AM (#6946403)
tptacek, widely known on this site for his coarsely abrasive, impossibly high friction, social interactions and not admitting he's wrong on issues trivial or important. He's also widely known for a being an expert in his field.

What are you talking about? Whatever caricature you're illustrating here is not Thomas Ptacek.

With the way you've been talking, I would've suspected you were a newer member, but you've been around for three years or so. So I simply have no idea what you're talking about.

Would you please point out precisely which comments you take issue with? https://www.hnsearch.com/search#request/comments&q=by%3Atpta...

I think the thing to remember about Thomas, and me, and everyone else, is that we're all human, and we all have different moods which influence our behavior. Thomas's, on average, is exemplary.

Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by bane on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:31AM (#6946732)
I'm glad to see that he's got both of us defending him.

I'm talking about the same tptacek who I've personally butted heads with where he couldn't even accept being wrong about how to make stew (looking back, that was exactly 1 year ago to the day!)

I respect tptacek very much for his domain knowledge and expertise. He has great theories on hiring practices and cooking among others. He's one of the names I look for on HN.

But he requires lots of care and effort. I have to mentally peel back about half of his posts to remove the snark and assholery and get to the juicy bits. But those bits are usually there and usually worth the effort to get to.

That's okay, I'm a grown up and can deal with high friction in order to enjoy interacting with somebody who's truly intelligent. tptacek is just one of those types that comes with lots of smarts and lots of difficult personality and that's okay.

And for the record I'm also aware that I can be rather high friction and assholish as well, and not nearly as insightful as tptacek.

Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by sillysaurus2 on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:42AM (#6946759)
EDIT: You know what, I'm not going to dignify this any further, other than to say that I don't want HN to be however you think HN should be. By saying "he requires lots of care and effort," you're discouraging people like Thomas from participating, and therefore making our community worse as a result. How would you feel if you saw someone talking like that about you?
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by bane on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:01AM (#6946798)
I'm not even sure what your responding to?! In no way am I insinuating that tptacek shouldn't participate here or that his voice isn't extremely valuable. I'm not being facetious when I said I'm glad we're both defending him.

I'm logically one of the last people to defend him here having butted heads with him so much, but in fact I deeply value his presence here.

> How would you feel if you saw someone talking like that about you?

I'd probably agree with them. I'm not a high-school kid afraid of how my peers will see me and neither is tptacek. I've said as much about his communication style to him directly.

I highly doubt that tptacek doesn't have enough self-awareness to know that he's a high maintenance debate partner. There's no reason to paint him as a saint, he's just a guy. A very smart guy, but he has his foibles and flaws, which are far outweighed by his contributions. But to ignore those more difficult parts of his personality does him a disservice by not seeing him in his entirety.

I respect the entire person (as much as I can see through the limited lens of HN) not just the parts I think are praiseworthy.

Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by MisterWebz on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:53PM (#6944666)
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6944628

> Jesus, what a tool you are.

How very civil and gracious.

Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by PavlovsCat on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:39PM (#6945134)
He deleted, i.e. retracted it. In full. To harp on about it instead of talking about the story kinda sucks. We're talking about mass surveillance and everything being recorded, and look at what we are doing. Repeat after me: every day is a new day.
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by antiterra on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:13PM (#6945037)
Sometimes it's tough to contain righteous internet rage. I think he knows that crossed the line and that is why he deleted the comment.
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by anoncowherd on Saturday December 21, 2013 @01:33PM (#6947457)
.. or he's doing Image Management.
Re:Secret contract tied NSA and security industry pioneer by InclinedPlane on Friday December 20, 2013 @08:01PM (#6945195)
He's a human being, and thus imperfect. He's still much easier to have a conversation with than 99% of the posters on HN.