c) Implemented voluntarily by the main four ISPs (three down, one to go), but with the expectation all will obey it because it's policy:
> "Preselected" parental filters are now official policy, and should extend to small ISPs, according the the Department of Culture, Media and Sport's (DCMS) new strategy paper.
... So, yes, it's not on every connection at the moment. But this is a government programme instituted by direction from the Government. When you combine it with the IWF and mobile filtering, it's not a misrepresentation to say that the Government is drawing up censorship lists and is approximately half-way through the job of making them unavoidable.
I take your point, but I don't think it invalidates the phrase "government controlled."
I agree they aren't all using the same software, and much is "voluntary." However, the UK web filter is:
a) In the 2010 Conservative Manifesto:
> establish a new online system that gives parents greater powers to take action against irresponsible commercial activities targeted at children;
http://media.conservatives.s3.amazonaws.com/manifesto/cpmani...
b) Announced by the government:
> all internet users will be contacted by their service providers and given an "unavoidable choice" on whether to use filters.
http://www.theguardian.com/technology/2013/jul/22/david-came...
c) Implemented voluntarily by the main four ISPs (three down, one to go), but with the expectation all will obey it because it's policy:
> "Preselected" parental filters are now official policy, and should extend to small ISPs, according the the Department of Culture, Media and Sport's (DCMS) new strategy paper.
https://www.openrightsgroup.org/blog/2013/government-wants-d...
... So, yes, it's not on every connection at the moment. But this is a government programme instituted by direction from the Government. When you combine it with the IWF and mobile filtering, it's not a misrepresentation to say that the Government is drawing up censorship lists and is approximately half-way through the job of making them unavoidable.