News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by walls on Friday December 20, 2013 @03:41PM (#6943853)
In my personal opinion, that's just something that will have to happen before engineers start taking the subject seriously.

If a year or two of NSA interns have to learn the hard way that they'll never find employment anywhere else afterwords, too bad. You can bet your ass that, by the third year, nobody will be accepting those positions without fully intending on being there forever, and committing to the degradation of privacy.

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by yeukhon on Friday December 20, 2013 @03:51PM (#6943930)
Yes, I do warn my lower classmen not to get those jobs. But schools can mislead them and the "internship" experience can mislead them. It doesn't matter whether how we try to prevent them from doing it, the issue is how we the cryto community, how we Americans, and how we the society perceives and accepts NSA employees (ex/current). It is this "discrimination" I am questioning.

I don't think I can trust someone worked at NSA for many years either. I will give you that. But how should companies deal with these applicants?

> If a year or two of NSA interns have to learn the hard way that they'll never find employment anywhere else afterwords, too bad.

And that's exactly why my question is important to raise: how do we choose not to "discriminate" them.

EDIT

Downvoting on a moral issue? Really?

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by walls on Friday December 20, 2013 @04:03PM (#6944006)
Again, just my personal opinion, but I believe they should be seen as 'tainted' and a potential threat to any employer, forever.

If we started ostracizing only long-term hires, the NSA would just have more motivation to 'turn' their short-term hires.

I feel that without a sort of "zero tolerance" policy towards NSA employment, there will always be a way for them to get around imposed restrictions.

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by girvo on Friday December 20, 2013 @11:37PM (#6945784)
As far as I'm concerned those kids made a choice. If they choose to help the NSA in any capacity, well then yeah I'd consider them tainted. They require a certain kind of person, and I don't think they have the best interests of worldwide privacy at heart.

FYI, you shouldn't have been downvoted, your argument has merit even if I disagree with it. Upvoted.

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by jlgaddis on Saturday December 21, 2013 @04:40PM (#6948186)
Off-topic/not related: out of curiosity, how are you aware that you're being downvoted? I didn't downvote you, FWIW, although I apparently have the ability to. Perhaps being able to see your {up,down}votes is one of HN's "incremental features" and I simply haven't been around long enough? Or maybe you track/watch your karma points? I can see mine, of course, but I don't think I've ever really paid attention to it.
Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by yeukhon on Saturday December 21, 2013 @06:23PM (#6948530)
it was -1 many hours ago. and now +7. And yes I can track by remembering how many points I get for each response. And next to logout tells me my total karma.
Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by jlgaddis on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:12PM (#6949029)
Yeah, just realized it shows it next to each of my comments on the "threads" page, sorry. Thanks.
Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by jra_samba on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:24PM (#6944506)
This is the key. Shunning.

NSA/GCHQ employees need to learn working for these agencies is a one-way street. No one on the outside will ever trust them or employ them again.

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by yeukhon on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:28PM (#6944525)
And we still need to resolve how to help people getting out of NSA and somehow get a job match their skill and experience. It is hard and it is hard for two reasons: 1) people don't trust them and 2) it is hard to justify their work outside NSA.

And I am interested in #1 how companies, particularly, big companies handle these issues, and do you as co-worker evaluate your new co-worker.

Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by sseveran on Friday December 20, 2013 @09:31PM (#6945434)
This would need to extend to the contractors at Booz Allen, SAIC, CSC, etc...
Re:Trevor Perrin requests removal of NSA from IETF Crypto Re... by aragot on Saturday December 21, 2013 @12:22PM (#6947200)
It is similar to any post-war country chasing the people who collaborated. In a sense, justice has to be made; in the other, the war courts usually assign surprising low penalties. The reason is, once the war is won, there's only revenge in penalizing losers.

... but the "war" of privacy is yet to be won. So chasing individuals for collaboration may be too early.