Re:The invisible hand that pushed Apple up and down for six ...
by nimble on Friday December 20, 2013 @12:56PM
(#6942829)
Eliminating the subpenny rule sounds like a good idea, but it wouldn't address the advantage of responding to news quickly, would it?
Re:The invisible hand that pushed Apple up and down for six ...
by kasey_junk on Friday December 20, 2013 @02:46PM
(#6943524)
It's not that it would eliminate it, but it would make the margins to due pure latency arbitrage so small as to make it not worthwhile (in theory anyway).
That said, there is and always will be an advantage to players that can respond more nimbly to changing market conditions (news being one input to this) and there is no inherent problem with that (and there may be lots of positives to the market as a whole).
Re:The invisible hand that pushed Apple up and down for six ...
by minimax on Friday December 20, 2013 @01:29PM
(#6943052)
Have you considered this post in light of the inverted exchanges BYX, EDGA, and BX? You can effectively make your liquidity cheaper by posting to an exchange with an inverted fee schedule (pay to add, rebate when you take), but we still see the "latency arms race" at the traditional exchanges.
Re:The invisible hand that pushed Apple up and down for six ...
by snowwrestler on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:19PM
(#6945559)
Moving the decimal point to the right just increases by 10x the volume necessary to create the same profit. I think a likely result would be massive consolidation to a couple big companies, who would then compete once again on latency but at much higher volumes.
If HFTs were all 100ms slower, I wouldn't care. But if HFT 1 is 100ms slower than HFT 2, then HFT2 will capture $0.03/share and HFT 1 captures nothing. It's a wasteful arms race. It's also fixable simply by eliminating the subpenny rule.
http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_whats_broken.html