News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by rwmj on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:16AM (#6940739)
Why not just opt out of the filter? Or use one of the many smaller ISPs who don't implement the filter in the first place? You don't need plugins/extensions.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by alan_cx on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:34AM (#6940786)
One opt out I've seen requires a credit card. One might not have one. Before you ask, me. I have an internet connection, but no credit cards.

Not all ISP cover all of the UK.

You also assume that the person wanting to bypass the ISP filter is the same person controlling the connection. So, say a 16yo wants to explore homosexuality, but is not ready to discuss this with parents who simply didn't bother opting out because they simply didn't think it was necessary.

Plenty of cases for using this extension, especially in the UK when we are routinely lied to about the scope of laws, and mission creep is universally denied, while it happens. For example, anti terror laws used by local councils to investigate fly tipping. We know that sooner or later other subject areas will be blocked by this distopian nut job government. Anything they feel is not in the public good will be considered and possibly censored. Make no mistake, this is the thin end of the wedge. We also know that it was originally dreamed up by the previous Labour government, so we wont get any changed even if we boot this lot out. Anything that bypasses these vile thought control freak nanny filters, and exposes the technical impotence of them is welcome. Remember, we dont have freedom enshrined in fundamental law. Its a granted privilege here, not a right. Oh, Human Rights act. Yup, this government wants rid of it. If Americans think their freedoms are under threat, the threat in the UK is many factors higher.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dingaling on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:33AM (#6941090)
> Not all ISP cover all of the UK.

If they use BT Wholesale backhaul then their coverage is exactly the same as BT Retail.

ID Net, A&A, Zen, many others will give you as much coverage as the big boys even in Market 1 exchanges ( only BT Wholesale provision ).

If you're in a Market 2 or 3 area ( lots of competing backhaul ) then there's basically no restriction to how many ISPs from which you can choose.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by rmc on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:35AM (#6941094)
You also assume that the person wanting to bypass the ISP filter is the same person controlling the connection. So, say a 16yo wants to explore homosexuality

Regardless of the child's sexuality, I'm sure 90% of parents think their teenagers are innocent pure darlings for years after their sexuality appears.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by RyanZAG on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:25AM (#6940758)
Opting out of a porn filter would probably see you added to some sex offender list within a few years. This is probably a better option if you're stuck on some ISP for some reason.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by treerock on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:30AM (#6940770)
I doubt it. Or I'm going to have some trouble. I reckon a large proportion of people will opt out and I wouldn't be surprised if they try to remove the opt out option in the future.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by TheAnimus on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:35AM (#6940788)
> I reckon a large proportion of people will opt out

HAH! I had a friend one day in tears because her bf had some porn on his laptop. She was shocked, outraged etc.

She owned a dildo.

Some people have horrific double standards, unless people make a stand against censorship (unlikely) or their desire for porn (even less likely). This is only going to get worse.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by gaius on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:49AM (#6940828)
I was both bemused and disturbed when it seems the entire female population went nuts for 50 Shades Of Grey recently. On my commute on the train on the way to work, you would see them twirling their hair, chewing their lower lips, writhing in their seats, sometimes even (subconsciously I'm sure) rubbing themselves. Can you imagine what would happen tho' if a bloke was reading a porn mag or watching a movie on his laptop? There is a huge double standard in play here.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by rmc on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:37AM (#6941102)
Can you imagine what would happen tho' if a bloke was reading a porn mag

That does happen. The likes of "Nuts" or "Zoo". Most of those lads mags are as pornographic.

The double stardard is that if a straight woman has lots of sex, she's a slut who should be ashamed; yet if a straight man has lots of sex, he's a stud and should be congratulated.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by gaius on Friday December 20, 2013 @09:09AM (#6941428)
I have not read either of them but I suspect we may have different definitions of pornographic. Are we talking photos of actual sexual activity here, or just girls in their underwear? Do you consider Page 3 to be porn?
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by pbhjpbhj on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:38AM (#6941876)
Pornography is defined by intention of the producer or by the action of the viewer/consumer. Page 3 is porn because it's designed to be sexually titillating. A picture which was taken showing someone's feet, say, may have been taken without any desire to be sexual but nonetheless can be used as pornography.

Nuts and Zoo and what have you have photos which are intended to be sexually enticing, ergo they're [soft] porn.

Generally the demos can control [via the government, to an extent] the production of works intended to be pornographic but not the private use of pornography.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dagw on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:50AM (#6940834)
In what world is that a double standard??? Enjoying masturbation and sex toys while disapproving of pornography seems like a healthy and reasonable stance to take.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by RyanZAG on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:59AM (#6941167)
I initially assumed your comment was a joke of some kind - but I think you might actually be serious? Could you explain how it's reasonable?
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dagw on Friday December 20, 2013 @09:04AM (#6941399)
Pornography is not created in a vacuum. There is a large industry surrounding it and, at least according to some, some of the practices of parts that industry is troublesome.

There are also reasons to believe that watching porn might in some scenarios affect the viewer in negative ways that abstract sexual fantasy does not.

Reasonable people can of course disagree to the scope and accuracy of the above objections, but I'd consider neither fundamentally unreasonable.

Masturbation on the other hand is almost universally considered a normal and healthy part of adult sexuality.

Basically just because someone might find porn degrading to women or morally objectionable, doesn't mean they in any way oppose sex and their own sexuality.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by RyanZAG on Friday December 20, 2013 @09:23AM (#6941495)
Dildos are not created in a vacuum and has a large industry surrounding it - and a lot of the practices involved in that are troublesome too. Sweatshops?

I'm sure there is pornography created by people who want to make it. I'm less sure there are dildos created by anyone who wants to be making dildos (the actual workers, not the boss).

I'm sure some people would find a wife using a dildo as degrading to the husband and morally objectionable. Probably most of the middle east. That certainly doesn't give me the right to call it bad, though.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by Myrmornis on Saturday December 21, 2013 @12:11AM (#6945853)
You've totally gone off the rails in this comment. The point is we can draw a line between commodities whose creation involves (a) people using their bodies in ways which vary from completely fine and consensual to coercion/slavery/illegal abuse, and (b) people working in bad conditions. In category (a) we have, e.g. porn and prostitution. In category (b), we have dildos, t-shirts and cell phones. There will be important discussions to be had about categories (a) and (b), but those discussions will be different.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by 4ndr3vv on Friday December 20, 2013 @08:51AM (#6941333)
Comeon, seriously? Do we need to talk about exploitation in the porn industry all over again?
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by highace on Friday December 20, 2013 @06:10AM (#6940885)
She probably didn't like that he was getting it on without her.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by pessimizer on Friday December 20, 2013 @08:30AM (#6941263)
I wouldn't say it's healthy and reasonable, but it's certainly not hypocritical.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by alan_cx on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:41AM (#6940804)
I would go with that if it were opt in. But deliberately, its not. Have to ask why, and what that implies. The whole point is to humiliate people who want access to porn. It has nothing what so ever to do with protecting children. The UK gov is enforcing a morality on the UK people which frankly its rarely applies to its self.

Also, BT are going to or are blocking proxy and proxy info sites. Why would any one want to opt in to that? Clearly this the beginnings of mass censorship, which I see no logical end to.

All this coming from the party which claims to be about personal choice and responsibility.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by nly on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:08AM (#6941683)
Exactly. In an opt-in system, enabled means "they displayed a preference against incidental access to porn" and disabled means "they've never bothered to change it". In an opt-out system enabled means "they've never bothered to change it" and disabled means "this guy irresponsibly exposes his kids to sleaze, and spends his free time downloading demeaning hardcore pornography".

We all know that, at some point, the status of some poor schmucks ISP filter is going to be used as supporting evidence of their lifestyle against him or her in court.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by hahainternet on Friday December 20, 2013 @11:16AM (#6942111)
The slippery slopes being written out in this thread are beyond comedy into absolute absurdity.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by pbhjpbhj on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:49AM (#6941929)
>Why would any one want to opt in to that? //

Come on, seriously are you saying you can't imagine why?

If you don't block proxies then you may as well not block anything. Regardless of whether you think not blocking anything is the better way - surely you can see why people would want to block porn on their internet connections?

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by cs02rm0 on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:38AM (#6940798)
Maybe not the sex offenders list, but there will be a list and it will likely be leaked in all or part.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by hahainternet on Friday December 20, 2013 @12:54PM (#6942816)
'Maybe'? The fact you don't know it's VSOR and not 'the sex offenders list' indicates you probably don't have a clue what you're talking about.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by mschuster91 on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:34AM (#6940787)
IIRC even the small providers have to implement filtering with the IWF blacklist, so there's no way to get a filter-free experience.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by c0n5pir4cy on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:46AM (#6940816)
There's a UK ISP called Andrews and Arnold that will give you a filter free experience with the caveat that you have to filter your own network, but they are not really a home ISP as such.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by timthorn on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:59AM (#6940856)
Why aren't they a home ISP? They have a product called Home::1 that is only available to home users. http://aaisp.net.uk/broadband-home1.html

You have no obligation to filter your own network, but you can if you want.

(A satisfied customer)

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by c0n5pir4cy on Friday December 20, 2013 @06:23AM (#6940919)
Well it appears I was a little misguided, I have a friend who uses them as a second ISP purely for office stuff.

He should me 24 hour ping latency graphs once, the network quality looked great.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by pbhjpbhj on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:51AM (#6941948)
Presumably they still block the sites like ThePirateBay for which court orders have been made?

I asked this last time A&A were mentioned, still haven't found an answer, just curious?

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by timthorn on Friday December 20, 2013 @11:28AM (#6942189)
Those court orders tend only to be served against the larger consumer ISPs.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by DanBC on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:28AM (#6941078)
Many people think that The Rev is a first class arsehole. Potential customers are warned to carefully research their choice of ISP.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by rlpb on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:36AM (#6941099)
> Many people think that The Rev is a first class arsehole.

You clearly do. But you said "Many". Can you cite any others?

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by DanBC on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:40AM (#6941111)
I could if Google Groups search worked, but it doesn't, so I can't. But there are many threads with him demonstrating his behaviour. People can decide for themselves if they think he's an arsehole or not.

He's not the Andy Mabbett level of trolling arse, and he's no MI5guy, but he does have notoriety.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dijit on Friday December 20, 2013 @06:05AM (#6940870)
they use openreach.

it's possible that openreach will be doing the filtering eventually, A&A have no say.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by timthorn on Friday December 20, 2013 @06:16AM (#6940897)
No, Openreach provide a bitpipe between the customer and ISP. The Internet gateway is with A&A.

http://aa.net.uk/kb-broadband-realinternet.html

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dingaling on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:38AM (#6941106)
IWF membership is entirely discretionary on the part of the ISP.

Even if the ISP is a member they don't have to implement the blocklist. ID Net is an example of this, I had an interesting exchange with one of the execs when I was a customer a few years ago. They were a member in order to 'monitor' trends but didn't use the blocklist. I don't see them listed as a member any more.

https://www.iwf.org.uk/members/current-members

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by dingaling on Friday December 20, 2013 @08:59AM (#6941362)
As a follow-up to myself, it now appears to be IWF policy that members must implement the blocklist

https://www.iwf.org.uk/members/member-policies/url-list/test...

which presumably explains why some previous 'observer' members are no longer members.

Again, though, IWF membership is not mandatory for any organisation.

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by treerock on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:24AM (#6940755)
Ironically, my work filters mean I can't access the site. But if it does bypass censorship then it makes a good political point. How much has this cost? How much publicity has it got Cameron? If it can be bypassed without any trouble then it is pure theatre.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by c0n5pir4cy on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:37AM (#6940797)
Lots and lots of really negative publicity here in the UK. It blocks rape support sites and sexual education websites better than it blocks porn:

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/gadgets-and-tech/abu...

Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by nly on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:17AM (#6941737)
The glaring public failures of this though will be either fixed or fade from the media. The system will remain imperfect but nobody will care 6 months down the line.
[deleted]
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by c0n5pir4cy on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:53AM (#6940841)
Yeah, I meant it blocks sexual education sites; I've corrected it now.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by srd on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:27AM (#6940762)
Why hassle with red tape if you can just sidestep the entire issue?
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by cs02rm0 on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:39AM (#6940800)
Political gesturing.
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by pbhjpbhj on Friday December 20, 2013 @10:31AM (#6941830)
I'm guessing the answer primarily is "because teenagers who don't pay for their connections don't get to have them unfiltered".
Re:Go away Cameron – Bypass UK's porn filter by rmc on Friday December 20, 2013 @07:34AM (#6941092)
This is a political move to counter-act the filter.