Re:UK Porn filters block sex education websites
by retube on Thursday December 19, 2013 @09:57AM
(#6934955)
> Restricting certain (legal, normal, non-violent, even educational) materials
I am not advocating that at all. The fact that the current filter technology may be badly implemented doesn't change anything with respect the basic premise.
> For a sect of the government to force this unilaterally, without any kind of democratic process, is a real problem in my eyes.
Every law in the land is made this way. It's not possible to have public voting on every piece of legislation. What you can do tho is vote in general elections. If a government passes unpopular laws they'll be voted out. My guess is tho, that like it or not, this legislation will have a lot of support.
Re:UK Porn filters block sex education websites
by vidarh on Thursday December 19, 2013 @10:00AM
(#6934974)
The vast majority of what these filters will block if properly implemented will be legal, normal, non-violent material. Quite a bit of it educational too.
Re:UK Porn filters block sex education websites
by mhaymo on Thursday December 19, 2013 @11:00AM
(#6935409)
> I am not advocating that at all.
That's exactly what you're advocating for. Pornography is all of those things. It is not evil.
Re:UK Porn filters block sex education websites
by retube on Thursday December 19, 2013 @03:38PM
(#6937683)
Huh, what? No no no. I am simply saying that there is some porn which should not be freely available. Educational stuff, soft porn, fine. It's the hard core, often violent, usually degrading to women, and in some cases, frankly unsafe/dangerous porn I have an issue with.
Like you I am currently on a work network so I can't really do any research, but I'm certain there will be plenty of claims of the positive effects of pornography (I have heard it said that pornography reduces sexual violence by providing a healthy outlet), and even more so other sex-related (and non-sex-related) material which is caught in these filters. For a sect of the government to force this unilaterally, without any kind of democratic process, is a real problem in my eyes.