News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by Locke1689 on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:30PM (#6930450)
> Don't see the argument for the intrinsic value of paper money at all, but would love to be enlightened.

You can pay your taxes in it.

Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by mrb on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:40PM (#6930529)
You could pay taxes using the German Papiermark or Zimbabwean dollar, and look at what happened to them...

Intrinsic value is not determined by the ability to pay taxes.

Fiat money has zero intrinsic value (well, beside the value of the paper and metal bills and coins are made of, but this value is negligible - spare the US penny coin).

Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by Locke1689 on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @04:08PM (#6930757)
Obviously the importance of paying taxes directly depends on the strength and stability of the government collecting them.

I am personally sure that 1) the US govt will be here tomorrow to collect and 2) they have enough guns to do so.

Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by mrb on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @05:04PM (#6931179)
Your original claim was that fiat currencies had intrinsic value. I don't see how 1) or 2) support the fact a fiat currency has intrinsic value. On the contrary, history shows that fiat currencies always significantly lose value over time. The USD for example has lost 85% of its value over the last 50 years. How is this observation compatible with any sort of intrinsic value? "Guns" and "taxes" did nothing to prevent this loss of value...

What you are trying to say, I believe, is that fiat currencies will likely have some value in the future because they are in demand (notably from taxes). That is true, but this is no different from Bitcoin: it has value because it is in demand. I would argue that the potential demand for Bitcoin is higher than the potential demand for USD, if only because there are billion of people across the world from countries with terrible fiscal policies for whom Bitcoin is clearly superior to their local inflation-ridden currencies. Compare this number to the merely 200 million tax payers in the USA.

Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by conanbatt on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:44PM (#6930566)
This argument comes again and again in this discussion, and I still dont get it. Why would you value something because it can be taken away? By that logic, increasing taxes makes the currency more valuable. Lets go to 99.9% taxes on dollars and see our money shoot to the sky!
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by umanwizard on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @03:50PM (#6930617)
Even if you had a job that paid you entirely in bitcoins, and conducted every transaction in bitcoins, you would still have to pay taxes, and (under the current system) they would still be denominated in US dollars.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by Locke1689 on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @04:11PM (#6930794)
Why do you value water? It's just something that can be taken away.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by conanbatt on Friday December 20, 2013 @04:17PM (#6944089)
I dont value it because it can be taken away. I value it because i need it to survive.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by Locke1689 on Friday December 20, 2013 @05:04PM (#6944388)
You don't value USD because it can be taken away, you value it because you need it to stay out of jail.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by sanderjd on Thursday December 19, 2013 @12:03AM (#6932998)
I agree that paper money has value, I'm just not sure that it is intrinsic. I'm also not sure a currency necessarily should have intrinsic value.
Re:Coinbase Crosses 650,000 Users by waterlesscloud on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @08:19PM (#6932275)
You know, there was a startup back in the spring that allowed municipalities to accept bitcoin for fees and taxes. Haven't heard any more about them though...