It may not be a failure from the ecosystem / societal perspective because a new idea was tested and discovered to have some value to the world, but the company ended up being worth $0. The founders are now saddled with a bunch of debt.
It's like you go all-in on a poker hand, and then lose to a better hand. Did you lose? Yes. What if you had fun playing? It's still a loss.
How did your hand fare against your opponent's range (and not just the hand they turned over)? If it fared well, you likely had good expected value on the hand.
Same principle applies to startups.
In poker, though, the stakes are smaller and you get to play many, many more hands to ease out the variance.
With your attitude, nobody would learn to play poker, because nobody ever wins the early hands. These guys clearly learned a hell of a lot, and that was likely worth more to them than whatever net profit they could have turned on working a different job. That's how I've always felt about my failures, anyhow.
Our goal was to build a large, thriving and sustainable business that profitably served lots of people, and eventually have some kind of exit event for our investors. Similarly we wanted to offer our employees an opportunity to build this business together.
We weren't able to do that and it's not Silicon Valley, but the expectations of the people who made a bet on us either with their money or their hard work that we feel we've let down, even as we know that most startups do not achieve this goal.
I'm sorry to hear that you feel like you've let people down. That's a terrible way to feel and live your life. Investors and advisors back you early on because they believe in you. Embracing that philosophy is liberating, and actually, allows you to take more risks and become more success (and happy) from my experience.
I'm sure they'll be supportive of your next venture.
Thank you for sharing your experience with everyone. I'm sure this wasn't an easy blog post to write.
I agree it would be bad to worry about this indefinitely, but early on I think it's normal and reasonable. If I were one of their employees, I'd certainly want to see them express that, so that a) I know they're decent human beings, and b) I can absolve them of their guilt on my account. Their being concerned allows me to be generous, which helps both of us.
> we believed by building a far superior product, and being creative about signing up users, we could turn long-distance carpooling from a niche activity to a modern mode of transportation.
> we did succeed at growing steadily (25-30%/mo), creating an Apple-featured iPhone app, building a userbase of 30k+
> we’re able to leave the Ridejoy website and iPhone app up and running for a while, until it starts declining in usage or requires too much maintenance
They set out to make carpooling great. They did it, and shipped the greatness to thirty thousand people. The service is still running.
They didn't make a fortune (or make their investors a fortune) doing it. So what? It is only in the utterly demented Silly Valley startup mindset that this is a failure.