It's not exactly fanboyism that makes security-conscious people prefer Linux. In fact, anybody with even a basic understanding of infosec knows that Windows should be considered wide open: Microsoft has backdoors, they give the NSA backdoors, and their code isn't open to peer review. Moreover, the Tor Freedom Host attack only exploited Firefox on Windows.
> Just using tails or whonix and being super paranoid...because security...is kind of a shit lifestyle decision.
Don't you think this is a little rude? Or even just presumptive?
"security-conscious people prefer Linux"...That's kind of a sweeping statement. What does security conscious even mean?
To me it sounds like this..."People who talk about security a lot use Linux by and large"..."but some of them are really partial to OpenBSD"..."and lots of Windows security experts really use Windows a lot."
I say that its a shit lifestyle decision because what is it accomplishing? You use this really restricted platform to make sure that people can't track you doing ??? What exactly? Communicating with your team of spy's??? Downloading midget porn??? Why do you think that you can have a single workstation that's good for every security corner case? What in the history of computer security makes you think that is a good idea or even desirable?
Let's take the example of the Iranian dissident trying to avoid the oppressive badies in their weird ass government...what does tails or Linux buy you? You are better off with the "throw away laptop" plan using good opsec and running tor from public places. Don't use it for anything but tor and tweeting your pics of black helmeted assholes. Get a new one as soon as possible. Rotate them with other people. The OS means next to nothing.
People keep conflating tor's uses with every possible InfoSec edge case. The dissident has different needs than a guy trying to make sure that the NSA doesn't catch him posting documents. The whistleblower has different needs than the guy buying drugs.
In all cases applying some critical thinking about what you are trying to do is a bigger exercise than "Winblows is the suxor at securitehz!"
Unix doesn't have a monopoly on security. I'm not saying windows does, but Unix people are kind of crazy about their pet platform.
The accusations of being a shill are also pretty annoying...but hey...
I'm not bashing people for using Linux...I'm saying that its not good security to say..."Linux is secure"...and not review your security needs from the standpoint of what you are actually trying to accomplish. I'm not making it out to be a holy war...I'm saying that people are just accepting that "Linux is more secure" on blind faith.
The OS provides a number of security mechanisms which make exploitation harder, Windows' reputation for security (or lack thereof) is somewhat well-deserved, ask anyone who has done exploit R&D.
Even if you have an FF 0day, you still need to be able to weaponize it, bypass ASLR/DEP/etc and this may be more or less difficult depending on the target OS
There are configuration issues that affect security that should be taken into account if you have high security needs. Its not a capabilities issue.
And you're right, I would call that configuration.
Here's a blog post: http://recxltd.blogspot.com/2012/03/windows-8-app-container-...
If you are using tor and you are using a web browser as your primary means of communication AND YOU REQUIRE SAFTEY you have already made a serious mistake.
Using a JSON or XML based API would be much safer since you aren't having to trust any level of javascript, css, or html...fetching executable code over the internet from a third party is the ROOT of the problem.
It all comes down to what you are trying to do...why are you using tor? who is your adversary?
Just using tails or whonix and being super paranoid...because security...is kind of a shit lifestyle decision. It can also lead to a false sense of security.