Re:Vatican, Oxford put ancient manuscripts online
by femto on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @05:59AM
(#6920482)
Perhaps the claimed copyright is groundless, on the basis the the scanned documents are well into the public domain [1]? Presumably the libraries are striving for faithful reproduction, which would imply no creative step, and a number of jurisdictions don't recognise "sweat of the brow" as being reason enough for copyright[2].
Re:Vatican, Oxford put ancient manuscripts online
by rmc on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @06:38AM
(#6920581)
a number of jurisdictions don't recognise "sweat of the brow"
A number of juristicions do though. Including (maybe) the UK.
In parts of the European Union, the CC-NC provision essentially amounts to a complete uselessness of the document, because of the weird definitions of the word "commercial".
For instance, here in Germany, if you have a blog, no advertisements, make no money out of it, but you have thousands of followers, you are acting in "commercial scope" (ie. you are too successful to be non-commercial), thus inviting all the nastyness of being sued for commercial copyright infringement.
The only thing I can do with a CC-NC document without legal risk is to look at it.
The sad thing is, that now nobody will bother to scan these documents and put them online under a different license, since "they are already out there for free!!".
It is quite likely that nobody involved with the project knew this, which goes to show how dangerous the NC-provision is.