Bell labs created the first transistor for goodness sakes. The photovoltaic cell. The first gas laser! Wifi! TDMA and CDMA. The CCD. Hell half the concepts of modern operating systems came from Bell Labs.
Mind you, Bell Labs had 90 years to do all this, but to even pretend like Google compares is hubris.
You can look at data centers before and after Google the same way people look at smartphones before and after the iPhone.
And Android didn't change things? Practically every new non-Apple consumer electronics device that has any kind of UI uses the AOSP.
Most companies don't run data centers. Of the ones that does, the vast majority don't look a thing like Google because very, very few companies have computing requirements that look anything like Google's
And Android didn't change things?
Changing the marketplace doesn't mean innovating. You can be very successful (as Google is) without leaving so much as a footnote in history of invention.
Most companies don't build transistors. Just sayn'
Most large tech companies perhaps but once you get out of a few major players this sadly isn't yet the case.
> Google essentially reinvented large scale data center management.
Almost everything Google has done are evolutionary refinements to long-running practice in HPC data centers which had long been doing automated provisioning and management, custom power & heat management, etc. for the same reasons: they couldn't afford not to.
While there's some mix and match, and Google and Amazon no doubt learn a bit from each other, how do you conclude that Google is the main reference?
For example, if I search for "how to run a data center" I find http://www.forrester.com/Five+Data+Center+And+IT+Infrastruct... , which talks about "Amazon. Salesforce.com. Microsoft. Rackspace" in the abstract, and does not mention Google.
I give Bell huge credit for the work they did - in most ways that is more important. But don't undersell Google's work in the fundamentals of AI science and their contributions to software engineering.
They were certainly a giant, even the giant, but the GP is giving them credit for other people's work. If the argument is "invention counts, refinement doesn't" in an attempt to exclude google, well, Bell loses out a lot as well.
Those "papers" do represent actual inventions, no matter how condescendingly you say the word "papers". And inventions only a handful of years old at that.
I'd venture a guess that many of AT&Ts inventions were (or would be, given a wider audience like we have today) looked down upon in a similar way - there were probably people who said "Ha! A toy like that? A couple of screws and some silly wires? We've already got _____ that can get that done, that clunky thing will never be practical."
---
Then again, I also think its a good thing that with more resources at our disposal we can take such a critical eye to work being produced by capitalistic companies, and as practices and inventions enter the industry, more easily take them for what they are really worth.
Google did not invent the search engine, they reinvented it. We can thank Google rather than anyone else (including Tim Berners Lee) for placing the wealth of the world's information at our fingertips. Walk into any office and you will see Google Maps on screen somewhere. Again, Google did not invent maps but it is Google Maps that everyone uses.
Thanks to the efforts of Google we no longer need to know 'general knowledge', i.e. the stuff that wins prizes in quiz shows. We can use our brains for storing more useful stuff. This is tantamount to evolution. As mentioned, keep up the good work!
[1] MapReduce is probably the most important thing Google researched but it only helps with companies' computing load, much like AT&T's telephony protocol improvements we never talk about.
Is this a joke?
One has niche uses and the other creates new industries and revolutionizes science. It's hardly the same.
None of the above is intended to diminish their achievements: in fact, I think the reverse is true because the industry history is littered with people who had great ideas and never really implemented them well. Big ideas just aren't worth as much as the many engineer-years of hard work it took Google to go from a concept to massive-scale HPC being a routine, commodity service. It's easy to say “Google succeeded because Larry and Sergey had two key Big Ideas” but that ignores the huge accomplishment they made in actually building a sustainable company which took those ideas to massive scale.
The biggest impact is Android, and that's revolutionary how exactly?
But what about all of the papers that have changed the way the world does computing? Some choice links below:
MapReduce http://research.google.com/archive/mapreduce.html
BigTable http://research.google.com/archive/bigtable.html
Dremel Paper http://research.google.com/pubs/pub36632.html
Chubby Paper http://research.google.com/archive/chubby.html
Urs Holzle on OpenFlow: http://youtu.be/VLHJUfgxEO4
Megastore Paper http://research.google.com/pubs/pub36971.html
Spanner Paper http://research.google.com/archive/spanner.html
Granted, some of these will take awhile before having implementations outside of Google... but you can't deny the impact of this work...