Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by nhance on Monday December 16, 2013 @04:47PM
(#6918057)
Every so often a company will make a move that is so smart that it boggles your mind. To me, this is one of those moves.
For a company so evil in so many ways, this really surprised me.
Think about this, if this works, low-income households can increase their earning power through learning skills that will allow them to make more money. Once they're making enough, they'll be more stable customers for Comcast and having used the internet to improve their lives, the internet will be one of the last things to cut. (If I was in the position to benefit from this, I'd never "bite the hand that feeds me" if I can avoid it.)
If they don't screw this up, Comcast stands to win hundreds to thousands of new lifetime loyal customers (assuming they don't screw up retention).
Low income families increase their earning power.Comcast wins more business. Khan is more successful. There are no losers.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by VLM on Monday December 16, 2013 @05:53PM
(#6918414)
Isn't comcast charging something like $10 for each 50 gigs over their transfer cap?
Next thing you know, the electric company will give the manufacturer of electric space heaters for poor people a grant so they can sell more and cheaper space heaters to poor people, or perhaps a for profit water company will give away free lawn watering sprinklers to poor people.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by unfasten on Monday December 16, 2013 @06:31PM
(#6918624)
Outside of a few test markets Comcast doesn't currently have a(n enforced) usage cap, and hasn't since ~May 2012. Prior to suspending the 250 GB/month cap they would warn you if you went over it (I believe they only actually warned a certain percentage of the highest usage users. I had gone over it before and never received a warning.) and if you continued to exceed the cap then they would suspend your account.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by MichaelGG on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:36PM
(#6918931)
$10 for 50GB? At 4 hours a day, every day a month, 50GB is only 1Mbps. 1Mbps of transit costs < $1/month. So in a way, it's only 10x markup, which isn't _terrible_ given the industry.
OTOH, people that exceed may be more likely to perform large transfers. If you're downloading at non-peak hours, there's zero extra cost to the ISP.
This kind of problem is unavoidable when the cost and price structures vary.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by cobookman on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:14PM
(#6919598)
Its not that rare to exceed the 300GB datacap if you're not using cable as your primary means of video distribution.
Netflix uses 2.8GB/Hour of streaming on its highest quality setting [1]. That's only 107 hours of video per 300GB. Now include four family members, and normal internet traffic...and voila you're over 300GB in one moth.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by chaostheory on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:27PM
(#6919236)
In most places (that don't have Google Fiber) Comcast is the best ISP in terms of speed for the money. Once you experience high speed internet, it's hard to go back to anything slower. This is a good strategy.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by 3rd3 on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:32PM
(#6919099)
It’s certainly going to be an interesting development how internet education will effect the socioeconomic backgrounds of intellectually successful people. This blog post [1] considers some possible outcomes.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by MrVitaliy on Monday December 16, 2013 @05:07PM
(#6918179)
Really bad customer service and overpriced internet for 90% of their customers, to subsidize a small, selected segment of new "low-income" customers. How much lower can they go as a company?
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by Datsundere on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:29PM
(#6918903)
This. I have comcast and we get 20mbps when our plan apparently according to the billing department is 50mbps. They say they'll transfer me to the "internet" service department, but they never pick up.
Re:Comcast Will Spend Millions on Khan Academy for Low-Incom...
by kbar13 on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:55PM
(#6918993)
Analogy:
You buy a pipe capable of pushing 50 gallons per second of water, but only 20 gallons per second of water comes out. Do you blame the guy you bought the pipe from?
For a company so evil in so many ways, this really surprised me.
Think about this, if this works, low-income households can increase their earning power through learning skills that will allow them to make more money. Once they're making enough, they'll be more stable customers for Comcast and having used the internet to improve their lives, the internet will be one of the last things to cut. (If I was in the position to benefit from this, I'd never "bite the hand that feeds me" if I can avoid it.)
If they don't screw this up, Comcast stands to win hundreds to thousands of new lifetime loyal customers (assuming they don't screw up retention).
Low income families increase their earning power.Comcast wins more business. Khan is more successful. There are no losers.
This is absolutely brilliant. Good job Comcast!
Next thing you know, the electric company will give the manufacturer of electric space heaters for poor people a grant so they can sell more and cheaper space heaters to poor people, or perhaps a for profit water company will give away free lawn watering sprinklers to poor people.
They are charging $10 per 50GB blocks in some of the test markets, with the base cap now at 300 GB. Details: http://customer.comcast.com/help-and-support/internet/data-u...
- WFH (syncing toolchains or source repos over VPN, or downloading VM images)
- Dropbox, or syncing disks to backup services
- Constant streaming of music from Spotify/Pandora/Soundcloud
- 1080p video
- Gaming
- Youtube
With a 120 mbps internet connection, it's pretty easy to rack up usage quickly.
OTOH, people that exceed may be more likely to perform large transfers. If you're downloading at non-peak hours, there's zero extra cost to the ISP.
This kind of problem is unavoidable when the cost and price structures vary.
Netflix uses 2.8GB/Hour of streaming on its highest quality setting [1]. That's only 107 hours of video per 300GB. Now include four family members, and normal internet traffic...and voila you're over 300GB in one moth.
[1] https://support.netflix.com/en/node/87
[1] http://www.gwern.net/Conscientiousness%20and%20online%20educ...
You buy a pipe capable of pushing 50 gallons per second of water, but only 20 gallons per second of water comes out. Do you blame the guy you bought the pipe from?