Groningen and the Nederland dont have any hills to speak off, but when you get to high speeds on a bike its good to be protected when you fall.
This law protects the biker against any trauma to the head while biking. Its is very easy to wear a helmet and a great way to be a role model for younger people.
Funnily, it seems that there is a distinct correlation between those that fight for their freedom to not wear a helmet, who also rail against “socialized medicine” and mandatory insurance, despite the fact that they will receive such care.
— a paramedic who has seen more than his fair share of non-helmet-wearing, non-vehicular-involvement bike accidents.
Compare to New York which has put in physically separated bike lanes on most Manhattan avenues and painted bike lanes on the narrower streets. Bike share launched in May and had over ten million miles ridden in its first five months. Almost no riders wear helmets. There has yet to be a single serious accident on CitiBike.
Melbourne on the other hand has nowhere near the same ridership yet there have been deaths. One was caused by a woman being hit by a tram -- no physical separation.
Yet the nanny state continues.
- proximity to cars (parked and driving)
- speed of cars when bikes are riding alongside cars
- speed of bikes (some bike lanes encourage riding too fast)
- visibility of the roadway (esp. in turns and at intersections)
- visibility of cyclists (mandatory front and rear lights at night)
- public attitudes and respect for each other (general civic politeness on the part of all road users)
- consistently marked and maintained roads and bikeways
- fairness in enforcing the rules of the road (both cyclists and drivers need to be consistently stopped and reminded or ticketed for infractions)
Bike lanes on their own don't solve all of the above problems. Putting all the blame in driver-cyclist accidents on the driver doesn't help build respect between road users.
If the cycling infrastructure is wanting (as it is in almost every major city), a helmet law is a good temporary measure to at least prevent some injuries.
This way, the job lies with the citizens. They can easily go pick up a helmet for cheap. It's up to them to pick the correct equipment now.
It really is not rocket science. If you want to make cycling safe you need:
1) Physically separated bike lanes, also on junctions
2) Traffic laws that protect the weaker participant
Contrast this little video from New Zealand showing a car hitting a cyclist and the police response [1], with a car right hooking 4 cyclists and causing a "bruised knee" in the Netherlands [2].
This video shows some infrastructure considerations in Groningen, a major city in the north [3] where incidentally I have yet to spot a single helmet or highvis vest.
Not that helmets are without merit. There is quit a bit of scientific proof that wearing leathers, helmets, neck restraints and 5 point seatbelt will reduce the number of fatalities of car passengers.
[1]: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fEgXQIAyGF8
[2]: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YeJ-d86pKsw
[3]: http://youtu.be/cWf5fbSUNAg