News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by jerf on Monday December 16, 2013 @09:29AM (#6914864)
"To realize that dream, however, he needs NASA to have a fully functioning space program when he's an adult"

Or, you know, he could get a job with SpaceX or Virgin Galactic or any of a few other companies (or the additional companies that will be founded once this becomes obviously economically viable) who eventually are going to need a manned presence in space for any number of reasons. Some of them will probably even be doing asteroid mining, or similar other cutting-edge tasks.

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by gkjohn on Monday December 16, 2013 @10:06AM (#6915113)
The fault in your logic lies at "once this becomes obviously economically viable". If and when it becomes economically viable. And even if there is "asteroid mining" during his lifetime, what makes you think that it'll be a manned mission?

NASA's space program has nothing to do with profit, it has to do with knowledge. And that can never be replaced by private companies.

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by WalterBright on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:28AM (#6915752)
> it has to do with knowledge. And that can never be replaced by private companies.

Many voyages of discovery were financed by private companies. For example, the Terra Nova Expedition was half financed privately.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terra_Nova_Expedition#Finance

and:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Discovery_Expedition#Finance

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by eru on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:03AM (#6915549)
> NASA's space program has nothing to do with profit, it has to do with knowledge. And that can never be replaced by private companies.

Why not?

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by quinnchr on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:16AM (#6915654)
Because long term research requires immense levels of upfront spending with no requirement to turn a profit.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by eru on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:56PM (#6919157)
IBM, Bell and Xerox are pretty well known for their research efforts.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by nether on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:15AM (#6915644)
Because NASA's mission is not to turn a profit.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by eru on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:55PM (#6919155)
Yes, but that doesn't say anything about companies.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by spiritplumber on Monday December 16, 2013 @10:15AM (#6915164)
The FAA doesn't fly airplanes, either. NASA's role will change once commercial manned space access is part of the environment.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by mktween on Monday December 16, 2013 @10:25AM (#6915227)
NASA's role isn't flying billionaires around planets for profit. That can happen through private companies just like its happening with planes now. Knowledge and exploration is NASA's game. No private company cares for those, so funding will come by the state. Its more effective then to fund NASA, than some private company that stands to make profit by doing it.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by jerf on Monday December 16, 2013 @12:44PM (#6916378)
The error in your logic is the casual assumption that knowledge can not be profitable. Hopefully the mere act of stating it is enough to show how untrue that is? And that's why there were private discovery expeditions, per WalterBright's point.
Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by loudmax on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:25AM (#6915724)
once this becomes obviously economically viable

There's the rub. Right now, SpaceX's biggest customer is NASA. Hopefully, space travel will become economically viable when this kid is an adult. It isn't there yet. It would be shortsighted to de-fund NASA before this happens.

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by jerf on Monday December 16, 2013 @12:38PM (#6916331)
He's 8.

Either space is going to become economically viable within his lifetime and there will be private actors that can take him on, or we're going to shut down NASA as a waste of time, because that is what it will be. The part that takes astronauts, anyhow; a desultory automated probe launching system may be left in place so politicians can pretend to people like us that it hasn't been shut down (and keep the pork network in place), but it will be shut down. (Indeed... by this metric... observe that we are about halfway there today! This is less forward-looking projection than an extrapolation of existing trends... for all the sound and fury about NASA's reduced capacity since the space shuttles were retired, very little has been done about it. And you can't launch astronauts on words.)

Merely having the government writing checks does not mean you get to forget about cost/benefit analysis [1]. If space can not provide benefits proportional to the costs incurred, it's not right or effective regardless of who writes the checks. It will be crowded out by other programs that do provide benefits proportional to costs. (Probably social security or similar wealth transfers.)

(My judgment is firmly on the side that it can indeed provide such benefits. It all comes down to atoms and energy in the end, and space can provide us with plenty of atoms that are rare on Earth (platinum, etc) and is simply awash with energy.)

[1]: It's probably impossible to overstate how much better off we'd be as a civilization and culture right now if more people realized this. You can not escape from cost/benefit analysis; attempting to do so merely virtually guarantees that you'll make bad choices. And lo....

Re:Child Donated His Piggy Bank to NASA Got a Call From an A... by mathattack on Monday December 16, 2013 @01:06PM (#6916531)
I'm very much with you on the cost-benefit of space. I think with every dollar, we have to ask, "Why not invest this in education?" and "Why not have the public fund this?"

For the former, I don't have great answers, and I struggle with it a lot. With the latter, there is an answer - neither public nor private equity markets have a long enough time horizon to sustain high risk investments for such a long time frame. (Especially if it's, "How do save the species in 200 years?" types of questions rather than space tourism) If it's important enough, we can't count on benevolent philanthropists.