News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by ge0rg on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:42AM (#6914364)
It is a really bad idea to compromise security for speed and connection stability. Processing power is a question of scaling the hardware, communication speed is hardly affected by a proper encryption scheme, neither is reliability of the application-layer protocol.

Usability, however, is a different beast. You must compromise security to make a chat application appeal to "regular" users. Still, this is a trade-off that can be clearly communicated to the user and to developers, and does not require a custom crypto protocol. You can achieve the same effects with using existing and tested libraries.

Edit: Disclaimer: I am the developer of the yaxim Android XMPP client and the operator of the public yax.im XMPP server (both available at http://yax.im).

Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by e12e on Monday December 16, 2013 @08:25AM (#6914534)
Thank you for the plug for yaxim. I've been searching around for a "good enough" jabber client for android, and while yaxim isn't there yet (for me: no otr support, single server) it looks like it's headed in the right direction!
Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by finnn on Monday December 16, 2013 @01:28PM (#6916730)
Have you looked at ChatSecure? It has OTR, multiple servers, all that good stuff. It's not wonderful but it ain't bad (curious to hear what others have to say, I haven't really used much else)
Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by e12e on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:58PM (#6919007)
I have it installed, but not really looked at it. My last "burst" use of xmpp was via facebook -- as most of my contacts don't use "plain" jabber right now. Before that I used it a bit for work -- but then rarely on my phone.

Now that google is killing talk in favour of proprietary hangouts, I predict it'll be a while before I'm a serious xmpp user again.

Sadly it's very hard to push process changes when one are in the minority in a group... Thanks for the reminder though, it does look like it full-fills most of my needs (and fixes annoyances I've encountered with other android clients).

Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by TelegramApp on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:35AM (#6915810)
MTProto still uses RSA, AES + DH. So I would disagree that what we have here means 'compromising security for speed and stability'. It is rather optimizing for speed and stability, while staying secure.
Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging by ska on Monday December 16, 2013 @05:00PM (#6918138)
Often in the crypto world, these are exactly the good intentions with which the road to hell(pwnage?) is paved.

Knowing this, I hope you can appreciate why the burden of proof on your unproven team and approach is fairly high.