Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging
by egeozcan on Monday December 16, 2013 @04:23AM
(#6913660)
I also don't get this. If we stopped trusting HTTPS, how are we supposed to make sure that we get an unmodified app from the play store, or the original source code from GitHub in the first place? Am I missing something?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The fact that we have to trust TLS to deliver software doesn't automatically mean that we should trust it for secure messaging.
Also, I think App Store software delivery doesn't depend on only TLS, but also on Apple's signature. And you can visually verify that the source code downloaded from GitHub doesn't contain backdoors.
My knowledge on cryptography is next to nothing. Would you mind explaining to me what makes the case for secure messaging different than any other transfer through a secured HTTP connection? I also read a bit on OTR Messaging and the "Socialist Millionaires' Protocol" but just got even more confused.
It's not that messaging can't use TLS, of course, it can. I'm objecting to the absolute (if we don't trust TLS for messaging, we shouldn't trust it one-time download), e.g. see https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Threat_model
HTTPS is fine, it's just all the x509 surrounding it that people are upset about
No, it's not fine. Currently the only secure version of TLS is 1.2 with AES-GCM; and it's still not deployed widely.
Re:Telegram - secure, free messaging
by timclassic on Monday December 16, 2013 @07:05AM
(#6914238)
Can you provide some more details for this claim? I'm interested.