>Leaving aside the fact that the author assumes that Republicans harbor the most sinister motives possible, while Democrats are purely altruistic; income is not a good predictor of party affiliation, (and vice-versa,) and the same is true for race
From the link:
"Democrats continue to have a wide advantage among those with incomes in the lowest quintile (under $20,000 in 2009 dollars). In 2009, 42% of lower income Americans consider themselves Democrats – virtually unchanged in recent years – while just 15% are Republicans, down slightly from 19% four years ago. But in the next income level up (those earning between $20,000 and $40,000 in 2009 dollars) the GOP’s decline has been particularly sharp. In 2004, the Democrats held a 13-point edge within this income group (38% vs. 25% Republican). Today, that has opened up to a 24-point lead (40% vs. 16%) as Republican identification has dropped off by 9 points."
But let's address your statement from your most recent comment:
>If you are in the top income quintile, you are almost equally likely to be independent, republican or democratic; how is income predictive of party affiliation?
If you are in the bottom quintile, you are not quite three times as likely to be a democrat than a republican, and the next quintile up, again, you are more than twice as likely to be a democrat than a republican.
That's still saying that someone who is very rich is much more likely to be a republican (even if they still only have a 50% chance) than someone who is very poor.
It's possible the answer is still yes, but it'd be interesting to see a breakdown.
This is correct, and I think you would also be correct to say political affiliation varies with income level, but that is still a far cry from income level being predictive of party identification.
If you are interested in more accurate predictors of political affiliation, you may want to read Jonathan Rodden's excellent work on geography and political identification.[1] To be clear, this work addresses the populations of areas, not individuals.