News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gahahaha on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:14PM (#6911180)
The author obviously understands that Bitcoin has no central bank - his point is that if it ever were to be used as a currency it would need one. Would you like your salary paid in bitcoins? You wouldn't know from one month to the next what you could afford to buy since prices would be so volatile. Bitcoin might have other uses like easy electronic payments - but the author points out that if you want to buy something legally it is quite convenient already today with the currencies we have.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by jpttsn on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:26PM (#6911256)
> it is quite convenient already today with the currencies we have.

That's ridiculous. The friction or transferring money is a huge problem across the world. Developing nations are left out, governments shut down payments on a whim, etc.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:30PM (#6911286)
I get my salary paid in bitcoin and I think it's pretty awesome.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gahahaha on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:53PM (#6911411)
From your other comments you seem to be paid in USD but your employer buys bitcoin for you each month and gives you that. You could buy the bitcoin yourself each salary day and nothing would change.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:59PM (#6911446)
Yep, basically. But what's your point? I don't want to do the extra work. I consider not having to a perk.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maxerickson on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:44PM (#6911351)
How flexible is that arrangement? If Bitcoin undergoes a sudden downturn, can you ask for dollars next month?
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:48PM (#6911379)
I get paid a USD equivalent. So if bitcoin went down next month, I'd just get a greater amount of bitcoin. I could change to being paid in USD instead, but I choose to be paid in bitcoin.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:20PM (#6911560)
If your salary is priced in USD, you're really just being paid in USD, not Bitcoin. When you're ready to accept a fixed amount of Bitcoin every pay period, then you're paid in Bitcoin.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:30PM (#6911609)
At the end of the day I end up with bitcoin in my account, not dollars. So what you're saying does not seem correct to me. The conversion is just a way of determining how much bitcoin I should be paid.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:36PM (#6911631)
Your dollars are being delivered to you via Bitcoin, but your salary is designated in dollars, thus you are paid in dollars.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:57PM (#6911704)
But dollars are not being delivered to me, that's the point. Bitcoin isn't acting as a middleman here-it's the end.

If I were your employer and decided to price your bi-weekly paycheck in terms of segways (each paycheck would be the dollar equivalent of one segway), does that mean you'd be "paid in segways"? No, you're paid in dollars.

You can't really claim someone is paid in dollars unless (1) they receive actual dollars, or (2) the thing they receive instead is guaranteed to be exchangeable for that dollar amount at any point into the future. Neither of these is true of a salary that is delivered in bitcoin, regardless of how it's priced.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:14PM (#6911772)
> Bitcoin isn't acting as a middleman here-it's the end.

No, Employer > USD > Bitcoin > You. If you're using dollar equivalent for any reason whatsoever, then that's what you're really being paid in. Your salary is being priced in dollars, not Bitcoin.

> You can't really claim someone is paid in dollars unless (1) they receive actual dollars, or (2) the thing they receive instead is guaranteed to be exchangeable for that dollar amount at any point into the future.

Yes I can. Your employer is paying out dollars, that it's converted to something along the way is not relevant, they're paying you in dollars; you just receive something else through a middleman, in this case the Bitcoin network.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maxerickson on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:33PM (#6911837)
I think maybe being specific makes things easier. His pay is clearly denominated in dollars and delivered in bitcoin.

I also think "paid in dollars" mostly means the pay is denominated in dollars, but I can see that being a language usage thing.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by coinbase-craig on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:38PM (#6911865)
I guess I just disagree. To me, what you are "paid in" is the thing that changes ownership from your employer to you on pay day. It seems like you are simply insisting that "paid in" is synonymous with "priced in," in which case this debate is just a matter of semantics and not actually very interesting.

Also, to begin with, this conversation was about what I am paid in, not what my employer pays out. In your last sentence it sounds like you are confusing them, or using them interchangeably. I see no reason that they should be considered the same thing.