I'd rather intel analysts have some cognitive dissonance than have absolute certainty they are always justified in their actions.
Unlike a lot of HN commentators who blindly follow the herd (i expect to get a ton a dv's for that)
Re:The NSA: An Inside View
by jessedhillon on Monday December 16, 2013 @12:43PM
(#6916368)
Seriously, you can't win. Here you have an actual former NSA employee giving a first-hand account of his time there -- and not only his account doubted for no reason other than failure-to-comply with known-biases and unverifiable journalism, but some guy is now providing psychological analysis of him as well!
Some know-nothing armchair psychologist who read the NYT is telling this guy -- who has made an honest effort to be utterly transparent -- that he's cognitively dissonant and that comment is going to receive a hundred votes because it makes people feel good about the things they think they know. It's not truth, just an exercise in mass delusion.
I've talked to this before but this denial and self delusion is an important defense mechanism. Sometimes people write blogs and get into apologetic because they feel an internal dull pain of an inconsistency. "Hmm it looks we NSA did all these pretty bad things. I worked for them NSA. Surely I couldn't have worked for the bad guys." and then <proceed rationalizing and defending NSA, might as well put it in blog form>.
That cognitive dissonance, I believe, is pretty powerful. A lot of dark secrets and past transgressions can be filtered so well throw it.