I expect that the blog post is sincere. If the NSA or another government agency wanted to manipulate the discourse on this or a similar site, however, they would (not could, would) do so by setting up a large number of active accounts over a long period of time. These would promote articles without triggering voting ring algorithms.
For the last couple of years I have been an active participant in a part of the blogosphere that is inspired by Unqualified Reservations, a contrarian ("(neo)reactionary") blog. I recently discovered that many of the (active and quite long-standing) blogs and commenters in this online community are fraudulent. It is the situation described in Wikipedia's article on COINTELPRO: "pseudo movement groups run by government agents". This includes people with whom I've had email and even a Skype conversation.
Since the realisation, I've managed to have a little awkward and plausibly deniable dialogue with these "bloggers" and "commenters". The message seems to be that they view neo-reactionaries as a group of potentially violent dissidents whose memes, if they were to spread, would lead to serious public disorder. So it's a political broken windows theory, in which the NSA or FBI are guardians of public opinion (although I happen to be English). Apparently they have been watching closely and collecting "data" for over a year.
So, mtgentry, I don't think you are too paranoid at all. (Although I would have done until quite recently.)
Realizing the potential awkwardness of this request from a stranger considering your message, is there anything publicly published about this particular situation?
Specifically: how are you so sure about what the NSA is doing? in your article you say that the NSA does not do SI on US citizens without a warrant, but how can you really know that if you are just another worker? I don't think you can... but hey, you seem like a smart person so why are you making that kind of statement?
> I was not asked to write this, nor guided in its contents by the government.
I find this hard to believe, especially coming from someone in your area: if there is no way for us to verify this statement, then how relevant can this comment be for us?
That's a bold claim - do you have any evidence that lorendsr, who is by his own admission no longer employed by the NSA, has been systematically lying again and again? Or that historically, part of his strategy is to try to influence society or specific groups? Or are you claiming that part of the NSA's employment process is the removal of independent thought and plugging into the collective hive mind?
I meant "you" the NSA, not lorendsr... I don't know him.
But yeah, sorry if my distrust of people who say they worked for a government agency that has as its main PR policy lying and manipulating public opinion sounds harsh... I'm just a bit angry because I'm not a US citizen and I know that my use of pgp,otr,tor,i2p,self-signed certs is enough to make some powerful organization start registering every single move I do on the Internet.
That is most likely the reason. Even reddit doesn't jerk this hard.
The OP's submission is a valuable one, even if you disagree with his views.
Are you sure about this?
The government tells you what is classified and what isn't. If you have ever been privy to any classified material, you will have made the decision to self-censor that information, to keep the essay unclassified. In other words, you will have removed information that the government told you it didn't want published.
Granted the control wasn't overt, but the government has influenced your writing via your past and the controls that were embedded when you went though your initial security induction.
If it works differently to this, please do explain it to me, as I would be interested to know.
I flagged it for my to-read list for after work. I'm an idiot and didn't RTFA.
This essay was deemed UNCLASSIFIED and approved for public release by the NSA's office of Pre-Publication Review on 11/21/2013 (PP 14-0081).
I'm quoting m8urn's post from upthread:
> m8urn https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6911796
> It all seems so sincere. Except when you see how closely this matches the talking points the NSA sent home with employees https://s3.amazonaws.com/s3.documentcloud.org/documents/8445...
I don't disbelieve you came up with all those points yourself, btw. Maybe you've never even seen that PDF hand-out. However, you couldn't have reworded this obvious piece of propaganda any better, if you did.
What I'd be more interested in is how much this issue is being discussed internally. If these discussions are allowed, or even surreptitiously encouraged, then I'd take that as a possible internal propaganda push, subtle as it may be. What's in the conscious mind gets written about, hence you'd see these kind of "justification" posts.
If there was very little internal discussion, or it was frowned upon, then I would expect much less of these blog posts, as it would potentially undermine your career...
I hate to sound like a tin hat wearing conspiracist. I really do. But I wouldn't be surprised if there was some sort of concerted effort by the NSA to encourage a dialogue with hackers on platforms like HN.
Sorry for the paranoia OP. Glad you enjoyed your time at the NSA.