News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Revisiting why incompetents think they’re awesome (2012) by KingMob on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:05AM (#6901183)
Former cognitive neuroscientist here. Yes, what you're describing, the illusory superiority effect, was originally demonstrated in Westerners, but found not to replicate as well in Asian cultures.
Re:Revisiting why incompetents think they’re awesome (2012) by j_baker on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:35AM (#6901376)
What exactly are "Westerners" and what exactly are "Asian cultures" in the context of the research you speak of?
Re:Revisiting why incompetents think they’re awesome (2012) by notlefthanded on Friday December 13, 2013 @12:53PM (#6901845)
I think the generalization here is in individualistic vs collective, and a difference in style of communication.

This sums it up pretty well: http://bsix12.com/east-meets-west/

Re:Revisiting why incompetents think they’re awesome (2012) by j_baker on Friday December 13, 2013 @01:18PM (#6901974)
I would posit that part of the reason behind differences in illusory superiority are due to a difference in how you measure narcissism between cultures. You can't use the same test in a Western culture as you would an Eastern culture.

Collectivist cultures aren't immune to the narcissistic problem. They're just narcissistic in different ways. In fact, I would say they're more susceptible to it. Look at the whole Chinese "Tiger Mom" thing. Asian cultures place very high expectations on their people just as Western cultures do.

A western narcissist would say "I'm God's gift to mankind". An eastern narcissist would say "I'm God's gift to the collective/family/cooperative".

For example, the Narcissistic Personality Inventory is based on the DSM, an American diagnostic tool. One of the questions is: Do you "prefer to blend in with the crowd" or "prefer to be the center of attention". I would imagine a more Eastern narcissist would choose the former while a more Western narcissist would choose the latter. Also, "I am more assertive" vs "I wish I were more assertive". People from face-saving cultures probably wouldn't even know how to answer this, while a Western narcissist would probably choose the former.