Re:David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
by Double_Cast on Friday December 13, 2013 @05:17PM
(#6903226)
Bad example. I can predict the dice game's problem space. E.g. for a single normal die (1-6), I can predict that I'll never observe a 7 [P(7) = 0%]. I can also predict the probability distribution. E.g. for two dice thrown together, the probability of throwing a sum of 7 is 1/6, whereas the probability of throwing snake eyes is only 1/36. Yes, the game's output is random. But what you're talking about is control, not prediction. If random meant "impossible to make predictions about", then statistics wouldn't exist.
Regarding winning, there's no way to improve one's chances (besides cheating?). But merely knowing that the game is predicated solely on chance can be useful for other applications. E.g. realizing that the lottery is a scam.
Personally, I'm in that camp that says reasoning is a instrumental value towards prediction.
Re:David Deutsch On Artificial Intelligence
by nitrogen on Friday December 13, 2013 @02:13PM
(#6902280)
I would define reasoning as answering a question or optimization problem, e.g. What is my best move? What is a good move? This can be formalized as calculating some kind of score for a possible action, whereas prediction is just about assigning a probability value to an event.
So would it be fair to summarize this as "reason is prediction with a goal"?
I would define reasoning as answering a question or optimization problem, e.g. What is my best move? What is a good move? This can be formalized as calculating some kind of score for a possible action, whereas prediction is just about assigning a probability value to an event.