Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ...
by hrjet on Friday December 13, 2013 @06:25AM
(#6900020)
> There is no advantage of prefetching images from familiar senders.
The advantages I had in mind were:
1. No leak of user IP address, cookies, etc
2. No leak of timing information (when user opened the email).
It will however leak that the email address is valid, which might be a fine compromise with a selected subset of senders.
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ...
by ithkuil on Friday December 13, 2013 @08:02AM
(#6900273)
Sorry, I wasn't precise. I was responding to the suggestion to only proxy for familiar senders. But, assuming that you can correctly identify who is familiar and who's not (there is scam detection as well), the benefit is minimal.
There is bigger benefit of doing this proxy for non-familiar emails.
Google could prevent leaking if email address is valid by simply prefetching images even when email is sent on non existent accounts.
The ideal thing would be to just prefetch all the images sent to existing and non existing accounts. This way there is absolutely no way for a spammer to tell whether an email is existing or not.