US pension funds (at least personal funds like IRAs and 401Ks) are pre-tax - that is the money you put into them comes from your gross, before you pay tax on it - you still have to pay the tax when you withdraw money (including any increase) from them - the idea is that you put money in to avoid tax at your highest marginal rate, and remove it and pay tax at a much lower marginal rate when you are retired. However you do still have to pay income tax on money earned in pension plans.
As to the fact that you can't claim the tax loss if you're unemployed or bankrupt, that was part of the thing I was trying to point out, buying your options after their value has increased can put you into a dangerous situation (I wasn't trying to justify it, just explain to the unwary that it can, and has, happened)
By your argument all US pension funds should pay income tax on any capital gains.
And just saying well you cant pay your tax we will take your pension is just taking the piss (to be blunt).
Forget reforming the NSA/CIA its the IRS I would be worried about