News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Physical reality of string theory demonstrated by DanielBMarkham on Monday July 06, 2009 @11:14AM (#689770)
It says the phenomenon was explained, not predicted. It's an interesting choice of terms.

I wonder if there is a difference?

Re:Physical reality of string theory demonstrated by sgk284 on Monday July 06, 2009 @11:42AM (#689814)
There is quite a difference.

Einstein swore that his very own equations dealing with quantum mechanics had to be wrong because it described a phenomenon known as quantum entanglement, which goes against all logic and seems impossible. This led him to believe that the equations were almost right, but with an error somewhere. To quote him, ""I find the idea quite intolerable that an electron exposed to radiation should choose of its own free will, not only its moment to jump off, but also its direction. In that case, I would rather be a cobbler, or even an employee in a gaming house, than a physicist"

It wasn't until a few decades later that we observed quantum entanglement in a lab... showing that the equations had in fact been right, even though Einstein had thought they were wrong.

The story in the op is a little different. A weird phenomenon is observed but unexplained... now an equation explains it, but you have to wonder if the equations were made to fit the observation. The best way to test this is to use the equations to predict some unknown and unobserved outcome, then see if the actual result meets the expected result.

Re:Physical reality of string theory demonstrated by jackchristopher on Monday July 06, 2009 @11:50AM (#689829)
If they mean the words how I understand them, you can explain something without making accurate predictions.

If I walk by a box and it falls over, I can theorize the the wind did it. That "explains" what happened. But it doesn't make my theory true.But say I predict that next time I pass it the wind will knock it over. So I walk by it again — it doesn't fall — then my explanation is incomplete.

That's why we require predictions. The real test is how accurate they are.

Re:Physical reality of string theory demonstrated by scott_s on Monday July 06, 2009 @04:58PM (#690442)
To expand on what the other posters have said, humans are natural storytellers. We want things to have a narrative, and we are bad at determining if a theory merely fills our desire for a narrative. Starting from a known phenomenon and crafting a theory around what we know should happen has the danger of creating a model that is too specialized or completely contrived.

If, however, the theory is able to make predictions about things we didn't already know, and those predictions agree with experimental data, then there's a higher chance our new model maps to physical reality.