I have an email I want to be secure.
Why am I giving this data to Lavabit in a form that they can decrypt? (Forget the government for the moment.)
Why aren't these systems engineered to mean that only _I_ have the key to decrypt them?
My point is that if I did want secure email, I wouldn't trust a company whose email system architecture meant that they could read my email.
A personal email server might be a good solution, but then you have to maintain it. It seems as though it should be possible for a company to build an email system (and offer it as a service to customers) whereby they _couldn't_ read user's email.
This seems like a good thing. (And as a nice side-effect, the government can't then issue them with a warrant to read your email. Although that's not to say they can't read your email in other ways.)
http://www.legaltechnology.com/latest-news/data-security-in-...
Because they didn't consider "because terrorism" to be a security threat that could penetrate privacy and property laws. Lavabit has proven that the Third-Party Doctrine means that once you give data to a business, you're giving it to the government.