Re:Top Reasons Why The BMI Is Bogus
by gb on Monday July 06, 2009 @08:43AM
(#689542)
I don't think the article is directed at people worrying about their own BMI, but when it is used by say, adoption agencies or insurance companies, etc. I seem to remember a case here in the UK where a couple weren't allowed to adopt because the man had a high BMI because he was a gym enthusiast or something.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I didn't think of that, quite honestly. You're quite right.
On the other hand, don't you agree that the actual problem in cases like that is rigid policy making with no regard for circumstances, rather than BMI itself?
It's both - basing policy on a bogus metric will almost inevitably lead to problems.