News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by kintamanimatt on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:07AM (#6894191)
I disagree. The headline is reasonable because you can be put in a position in which you're not forced to do something, but it's extremely unreasonable not to do that thing. They weren't forced to close down per se, but their other options were extremely infeasible or reprehensible.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by Bahamut on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:19AM (#6894226)
Arguably it is a problem they created by the architecture they chose, in which this is a fatal flaw of design that was almost certainly something that could be anticipated.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by kintamanimatt on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:27AM (#6894253)
I do agree, but historically we've been able to write software in an environment we didn't foresee being hostile. We've been too trusting and blasé when it comes to privacy and security. For example, look at the original SMTP implementation: the designers didn't take into account there might be governments or other bad actors that would snoop wholesale on such messages as they bounced around the infrastructure. If the original designers had known, the specification would have undoubtedly been different.

It's also hard to create a system that's private and secure, and it's vastly less convenient to use which increases friction and drives down adoption. PGP, for example, is very good but extremely inconvenient to use all the time.

As an outsider, I think I understand the rationale behind their design decisions. Just saying it should have been more carefully created with privacy in mind glosses over the many complexities and difficulties that design goal entails.

We, as creators of software, have problems that are more political than technical, no matter where we are in the world.

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by jackgavigan on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:33AM (#6894278)
> They weren't forced to close down per se...

That's the crux of the issue. They weren't forced to close down, they chose to.

End of discussion.

EDIT: Actually, why don't we see what the CEO of CertiVox has to say on the matter?

"The headline strongly infers our friends at GCHQ “forced” us to take PrivateSky down. That’s hogwash."

Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6894316

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by kintamanimatt on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:43AM (#6894324)
End of discussion? No, sir, it is not!

Your interpretation is extremely naïve. I could hold a gun to your head, for example. You wouldn't be forced per se to meet my demands, but you probably would because it would be extremely unreasonable not to. In the same way, the consequences for not complying are: an extremely expensive and possibly unaffordable rewrite, going to jail for a few years, or giving up their customers data in violation of their principles. The GHCQ order effectively put a gun to their head.

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by res0nat0r on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:50AM (#6894671)
Sounds like these services actually shutting down is a good thing for the end users, since they aren't actually securely designed in the first place! They even admit in the article they'd have to properly design their system to make email unreadable by their staff, and they chose to shutter their service vs trying to figure out how to make that work and still make money.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by jackgavigan on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:43AM (#6894639)
> I could hold a gun to your head, for example. You wouldn't be forced per se to meet my demands, but you probably would because it would be extremely unreasonable not to.

GCHQ never demanded that CertiVox shut down their service. That is the bottom line and, no matter what sort of ridiculous "gun against your head" rationale you come up with or how firmly you plug your ears while shouting "LALALA!" at the top of your voice; you cannot refute that fact.

EDIT: Actually, why don't we see what the CEO of CertiVox has to say on the matter?

"The headline strongly infers our friends at GCHQ “forced” us to take PrivateSky down. That’s hogwash."

Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6894316

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by teamgb on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:37AM (#6894959)
Sir Ian, nice try, but we know it's you!

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iain_Lobban

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by kintamanimatt on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:48AM (#6894660)
I think you should direct your fingers-in-ears comment towards yourself. In any event, I can't make a further argument without being repetitive.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by lttlrck on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:01AM (#6894407)
Why is it extremely unreasonable to not comply when there is a gun at your head but not in this case?
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by kintamanimatt on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:06AM (#6894430)
I think you've misread what I wrote.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by alan_cx on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:45AM (#6894330)
So if I put a gun to your head, and you give me money, you haven't been forced to, right?

Are you PG? No? Then who are you to decide when a discussion ends round here?

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by jackgavigan on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:40AM (#6894618)
> So if I put a gun to your head, and you give me money, you haven't been forced to, right?

Wrong. I HAVE been forced. You have threatened me with death if I don't comply with your demand.

GCHQ never demanded that CertiVox shut down their service. They (or, rather, the Home Secretary) demanded that they hand over the key(s) required to decrypt one (or more) of CertiVox's customer's data.

If CertiVox took it upon themselves to then shut down the PrivateSky service, that is their choice. But it is a lie to claim that GCHQ forced them to.

CertiVox could claim that they "felt they had no option but to shut down the service" or that they "could no longer, in all conscience, continue to offer and market a service that" blah blah blah but, the fact is that they always knew that PrivateSky was vulnerable to section 49 notices.

RIPA's been on the statute books for over a decade and section 49 has been in force since 2007. CertiVox launched PrivateSky in 2011, which means that they either built a service that they knew was vulnerable to RIPA disclosure requirements or they didn't know about RIPA. I don't believe that they didn't know about RIPA.

It doesn't matter what special snowflake rationale you come up with about what's reasonable or unreasonable. The simple fact of the matter is that the headline is misleading. GCHQ did not force PrivateSky to shut down.

EDIT: Even the CEO of CertiVox refutes the claim that GCHQ forced the closure of PrivateSky!

"The headline strongly infers our friends at GCHQ “forced” us to take PrivateSky down. That’s hogwash."

Source: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6894316

Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by teamgb on Thursday December 12, 2013 @10:34AM (#6894946)
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by hash9 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @01:25PM (#6896089)
Going through the thread calling people names. Keep it classy teamgb.
Re:CertiVox confirms it withdrew PrivateSky after GCHQ issue... by RobAley on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:41AM (#6894315)
Nope, the beginning of one. Life is never black and white like that.