I'm not talking about a difference of degree where one stimulant is "more powerful" than the other, but in the nature of the effects. "CNS stimulant" is a very vague term which glosses over really major differences between, say, amphetamine and caffeine.
I'm not sure in what sense you mean "zero sum" but it isn't true of amphetamine in the senses that come to mind.
One good reason to legalize stimulants is to let more people experiment with them. It would be great to know that taking amphetamine is actually a bad way to work in the long term.
Either way, I'm more excited about non-stimulant methods of increasing concentration. Stimulants seem zero sum, at best.