Re:The abolition of work
by yummyfajitas on Sunday July 05, 2009 @06:11PM
(#688793)
The point I made was somewhat more limited than what I think you are arguing against. Obviously, wealth needs to be properly allocated or it is useless. However, my argument was merely that the solution to one particular problem ("how to care for people replaced by robots") would be cheap in the particular future envisioned.
Consider how this might work in modern terms. If you can't survive in the modern economy, you are provided with food and a bed to sleep in. We actually have such a system (homeless shelters + soup kitchens) and the cost of providing it is a negligible fraction of our GDP.
The problem comes when you try to add too much to this basic package, or when corruption eats up big chunks of wealth. I don't disagree with any of that.
And you are probably right about jealousy: people will feel poor when they get free health care but immortality pills are only for the rich. But that's a separate issue.
Consider how this might work in modern terms. If you can't survive in the modern economy, you are provided with food and a bed to sleep in. We actually have such a system (homeless shelters + soup kitchens) and the cost of providing it is a negligible fraction of our GDP.
The problem comes when you try to add too much to this basic package, or when corruption eats up big chunks of wealth. I don't disagree with any of that.
And you are probably right about jealousy: people will feel poor when they get free health care but immortality pills are only for the rich. But that's a separate issue.