News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by gaius on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:01AM (#6886970)
Oh come on. No one robs a granny to buy another single malt. There are people who abuse anything, sure. But it's a stretch to say alcohol is a net negative on society, millions of people enjoy a drink. But crack unquestionably is.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by mattgibson on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:17AM (#6887032)
It's no stretch at all. If you read his article, they discriminate between 'bad for the users' (crack is worse) or 'bad for society' (alcohol is worse). http://www.theguardian.com/society/2010/nov/01/alcohol-more-...

Alcohol is toxic to most major organs, is one of only a tiny number of drugs that can make normally passive people become violent, and is the world's most prolific date-rape drug. If you've ever seen the emergency room in a typical hospital on a Saturday night, you'd see that many of the millions who enjoy a drink get violent and antisocial, injuring themselves and others. Then there's domestic abuse, drunk driving, risky sex, etc etc.

You'd need to take figures on all of those effects into account before deciding whether it's a 'stretch' or not. Which is exactly what Prof. Nutt did in his paper.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by matthewmacleod on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:02AM (#6887173)
That's a total non sequitur, given that I was objecting to this silly personal attack.

I do not believe that alcohol is a net negative to society. I'm pretty confident that crack cocaine is more damaging, especially to the individual user (and in fact you'll find that borne out by Nutt's research).

However, while perhaps "nobody robs a granny to buy a single malt," alcohol can very obviously have damaging effects, especially if it's misused. Sexual assault and drunk driving are just two examples.

That these exist does not mean that alcohol should be banned, and that crack is more damaging does not mean that the most effective tool to prevent it's use is criminalisation.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by aneisf on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @10:54AM (#6888213)
>Oh come on. No one robs a granny to buy another single malt.

No, they rob granny to buy another bottle of $15 vodka.