News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:28PM (#6885717)
Disagree. The US bases all of it's drug laws after the UN Single Convention on Narcotic Drugs (Which arguably was US engineered)[1]. So the federal government has an international treaty obligation to create and enforce drug laws.

This is the major distinction between Cannabis prohibition and Alcohol prohibition. The latter could be turned off by the US government, the former requires snubbing the UN. There is always the unilateral option but the US wouldn't do that in this case because it would open the gates for every other country and the political interests are way too strong.

Basically for the US to formally "legalize it" the rest of the world would have to as well, which is why Argentina and Uruguay are great examples of leadership when it comes to the Drug war; they are both UN members and implied signatories to the treaty.

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Single_Convention_on_Narcotic_D...

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by insickness on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:47PM (#6885783)
The US hardly ever takes its cues from the UN. It's fairly obvious that if the US wants to take action that's not sanctioned by the UN, it will find a way to take that action or get the UN to follow along. The difficult part here is the US changing it's internal stance on drugs. Compared to that, dealing with the UN is a piece of cake.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:49PM (#6885950)
That's also not true. The vast majority of UN treaties which the US is a signatory to are enforced by the US* on US citizens. If your claim is that we only enforce the ones we lead on then that is an impossible claim to prove - by design. 99% of UN treaties no one will ever know of, things related to fisheries, wildlife preservation, telecommunications, arms control etc... check it out for yourself on their database [1]

There are of course major examples of unilateral actions on the part of the US to be sure, but those are outliers albeit extreme ones.

[1] http://treaties.un.org/pages/ParticipationStatus.aspx

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by leoedin on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:41AM (#6886921)
I think you're mistaking the order of action. Yes, the US is a signatory to many UN treaties, but this isn't because the UN released the treaty and the US reluctantly signed up. The US is a founding member of the UN, and uses the body to enforce American values on the world. The UN convention on narcotics is a product of the US war on drugs, not the other way round. The US use trade sanctions as a stick to force others to sign up.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by adventured on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:55PM (#6885820)
That treaty doesn't mean anything, it has no teeth. The US can choose to not abide by it (as it is already doing), or opt out of it at will (as it will do), and there will be no consequences under any circumstances, period.

As is the case with most things related to the UN as it applies to the US, the US can ignore it tomorrow morning, and there is absolutely nothing that will or can realistically be done about it. Who is going to do what, exactly? The US is by far the prime leader in the war on drugs, if we fold our cards, it's instantly game over, no matter what half-cocked treaties are outstanding.

Enforcement is purely optional at this point already, as has already been demonstrated in Washington and Colorado, and a lot more are going to follow.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by AndrewKemendo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:58PM (#6885978)
The US is by far the prime leader in the war on drugs, if we fold our cards, it's instantly game over, no matter what half-cocked treaties are outstanding."

Hence my previous statement:

There is always the unilateral option but the US wouldn't do that in this case because it would open the gates for every other country and the political interests are way too strong.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by toyg on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:49AM (#6886631)
>the political interests are way too strong.

What political interests? Most European elites are begging for the US to come around so that they can have the political cover to drop this madness. They cannot do that until World Police changes its stance, because they'd be commercially blacklisted into the Middle Age.

The political interests were there when the US could use drug policy to support this or that puppet government in Latin America or Afghanistan. This strategy has failed so thoroughly in the long run, your own backyard is now giving up and leading decriminalisation. The US government would get a lot of goodwill around the world by ending the prohibition idiocy.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by bananacurve on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @09:30AM (#6887756)
>because they'd be commercially blacklisted into the Middle Age

Portugal was blacklisted to the middle ages? Eventually Europeans will have to stop pretending everything is the US's fault and be responsible for their own countries.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by toyg on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @10:50AM (#6888184)
Portugal decriminalised a bit more than others, they didn't legalise. Other countries have done something similar, but full legalisation would incur the wrath of US representatives at UN, WTO etc.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by dbpatterson on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:46PM (#6885778)
Funny, the US seems perfectly willing to ignore the UN when it wants to (for example, environmental agreements). Not sure why this would necessarily be any different.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by toomuchtodo on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:55PM (#6885815)
Or drone strikes against civilians?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by sb057 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:48PM (#6885785)
Is Uruguay not also under that Convention?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:41AM (#6886759)
Yup. They've decided they don't care. Nothing will happen beyond what has already happened - a strongly worded letter.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by shubb on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:41PM (#6889138)
You stumble across something wider and interesting - representatives of democratic states writing international conventions to create obligations to implement unpopular laws.

We see this in the response to copyright infringement too e.g. ACTA - the executive thinks this is a thing that needs doing, but will never get past elected representatives because the public doesn't like it.

A lot of the hostility towards Europe stems from it's constituent governments using it like this.

Is this a reaction to a flaw in democracy?

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by namlem on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:39PM (#6889110)
The US snubs the UN all the time. If pressure from the voters becomes strong enough, we'll do it. UN convention or not.