Re:Some things to do (and not do) if you aren't invited to i...
by adrianwaj on Tuesday October 16, 2007 @08:48PM
(#68846)
I would expect that in a more perfect world PG (or an equivalent) would also say "We also like to give feedback and point out the things that would have made us more interested had it been included."
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Some things to do (and not do) if you aren't invited to i...
by sbraford on Tuesday October 16, 2007 @10:29PM
(#68890)
The common refrain from VCs, book publishers -- anyone who gets large volumes of submissions and can only select a tiny minority is:
* even attempting to respond (however briefly) to the deluge of requests would overwhelm us to the point that we could no longer focus on running the core business
Re:Some things to do (and not do) if you aren't invited to i...
by adrianwaj on Wednesday October 17, 2007 @01:52AM
(#68962)
But, if all publishers gave feedback then the 'poor' authors would each save themselves from submitting to multiple publishers, and the 'poor' publishers deluged with submissions would instead have more refined manuscripts to evaluate and in lesser numbers. Thus, a little feedback can go a long way. This is because ideally manuscripts would improve only after a few submissions due to the feedback given and then they would either be accepted for publishing, referred to a more appropriate publisher, or shelved due to uninterested publishers.