News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by gress on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:39PM (#6883919)
The post is right, and even more so for developing world cities that emerged before cars were around.

However the post is also naive. Cars are usually much faster, provide much better shelter from the weather, and are much less tiring than trying to lug bags from one place to another on buses or other public transport. They also place far fewer constraints on when you can travel.

Of course it's possible to structure one's life so as to deal with all of the issues. I have lived half of my adult life without a car, including 4 years in the SF Bay Area, and I managed.

But let's stop pretending that there isn't a trade off. Cars are very very convenient. The key to reducing the need for cars is not just good public transport - it's services that reduce the reliance on traveling to get chores done. Things like grocery deliveries, laundry pickup, and amazon.com.

It would be a lot easier to rely solely on public transport if you never had to carry anything.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by rayiner on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:56PM (#6884047)
I lived car-dependent in Atlanta, without a car in Chicago and New York, and am car-dependent again in Wilmington, DE. The burden of carrying things never matched the hassle of circling around somewhere looking for a parking spot.

Indeed, living in the New York City suburbs with a baby and no car (but on a train line) was way more convenient than living in Wilmington with a car. Running down the block to the store and shoving some items in the stroller basket is infinitely easier than putting the baby in a car seat, folding the stroller into the trunk, driving 12 miles to the strip mall, taking the baby out of the car seat, unfolding the stroller out of the trunk, putting the baby back in the car seat, folding the stroller into the trunk, driving 12 miles back from the strip mall, then finally taking the baby back out of the car seat and unfolding the stroller out of the trunk.

It's as inconvenient and frustrating as it sounds.

People have preferences, sure, but I'm sick of subsidizing suburbanization with my tax dollars. The public sector spends about $150 billion per year building and maintaining highways: http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/ftpdocs/120x.... That's not counting local roads and streets. Nobody blinks an eye at that. But they freak out that Amtrak has been given $13 billion in federal subsidies in the 40 years since 1972.

And don't get me started on the tax breaks for mortgages that disproportionately benefits suburbanites, etc. My wife and I have no problem with how much taxes we pay, but it drives us crazy that my parents pay a substantially lower rate despite making more money because they can deduct fully deduct the interest on their $1 million mortgage for their suburban McMansion. Meanwhile, my wife and I are phased out of student loan and childcare deductions despite making less money.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by selmnoo on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:52AM (#6886948)
> People have preferences, sure, but I'm sick of subsidizing suburbanization with my tax dollars. The public sector spends about $150 billion per year building and maintaining highways: http://www.cbo.gov/sites/default/files/cbofiles/ftpdocs/120x.... That's not counting local roads and streets. Nobody blinks an eye at that. But they freak out that Amtrak has been given $13 billion in federal subsidies in the 40 years since 1972.

Wow, never thought about it like that. Thanks for the comment.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by tdees40 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:45PM (#6883971)
The odd thing to me about cars is that people pick the most unusual use cases and then buy their cars off of that. So my dad likes to haul plywood once in a while, so he bought a pick-up. But 99.99% of the time he could use a subcompact. Likewise everyone knows people who have two kids and buy a van/SUV because they want an extra seat or two. You can always rent a car if you get into these sorts of situations, and it would be much cheaper than buying a huge car that runs with one person in it 90%+ of the time.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:01PM (#6884089)
Is it really that odd? We do the exact same thing with computers. How often, exactly, are we max'ing all 16GB of RAM and pegging all eight cores of our workstations? Couldn't we "just" rent time on EC2 when we need more?

Yes, it's a pain in the butt to farm out most types of compute to EC2. Yes, it can quickly get expensive. Yes, you can save money buying a $40 Sempron. All these arguments and obstacles can be applied just as well to buying a 2-seater subcompact and renting other cars, so before we decry it as "weird" and "making no sense", maybe we should reflect on our own decisions?

Re:Cars Kill Cities by TulliusCicero on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @08:43PM (#6885350)
1. Buying extra RAM or a faster CPU is almost always super cheap compared to buying a bigger car (consider both initial price and reduction in fuel efficiency).

2. Farming computing out to EC2 is nothing like renting a car.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by dllthomas on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:00PM (#6884079)
It may not be unreasonable if the overhead to rent is high. It's coming down, though I have no idea what ranges are "too high" or where things currently stand relative to that.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by msandford on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:15PM (#6884177)
It's not even the monetary cost of renting, it's the time cost. If I have a pickup truck the time cost for me to buy something off of CL is driving there, inspecting it and then buying it. Done.

If I have to rent a pickup to transport it back then I've got two choices. I can either rent the vehicle prior to looking at the item or after I decide to buy it for sure. If I always-rent then I'll kill at least 2hrs per CL purchase due to having to go to somewhere to rent said vehicle. If I rent-after-inspection I'll save those 2hrs when I don't buy at the expense of making two trips every time I do buy. Neither one is an attractive option.

Two hours according to what they pay me is no joke in terms of cash so in either case if this happens say twice a month I've paid for the total difference between owning a subcompact and a pickup truck: note, gas, insurance, etc.

I don't actually own a pickup truck and most of the time the things I pick up fit in my Forester just fine. But it's not unreasonable to make such a decision when you think through how much of a disaster it is to try and rent a vehicle on a semi-regular basis.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:49PM (#6884411)
For the price delta between my Yaris and a gigantic 4x4 crew cab pickup truck, including capital cost, interest, insurance, gas, maint, tires, if I buy a small car I'll never, ever have to buy anything used again off craigslist.

This is stereotypical penny wise pound foolish behavior. WRT to OP's relative hauling some plywood occasionally, for the price difference between a commuter car and a monster truck he could find a young man, pay his living expenses while he completes a complete carpentry apprenticeship, and pay the young man for some materials, and the young-ish journeyman could come out and do all the work for him as a thank you.

Another way to put it is the price differential is about 3x what I paid for a new roof on my house... all to haul some plywood...

When I put in a patio I had a flatbed truck deliver two pallets of bricks, two pallets of gravel and a pallet of sand bags. The delivery fee was roughly the delta between one months payment for a car vs a truck. You'd be surprised how much labor you can get out of a truck driver for $200 or $300 or so, and he was probably happy with me because the job only took him maybe 2-3 hours total.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by msandford on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @08:19PM (#6885268)
Sure but you're calculating the ideal case for you and worst-case for the truck. Not everyone buys a gigantic 4x4 crew cab pickup. There are plenty of regular bed length, single cab RWD pickups on the road and they don't cost $60k to buy.

The Ford F150 base model goes for $25k or so.

http://www.ford.com/trucks/f150/pricing/

A base model Yaris goes for $14k.

http://www.toyota.com/yaris/#!/Welcome

And that's presuming you're buying new! There are a great many used pickups for sale and the parts tend to change less frequently because pickup design parameters change much more slowly than car design parameters do. Because the design changes more slowly parts tend to be around longer and cheaper. And because the design of a pickup is driven by the need to have a 4x6-8ft long bed they tend to have roomy engine compartments in order to keep the proportions "correct"

By your own admission if you did at least one project per month requiring the use of a truck you would be spending the same amount of money. Perhaps that's money well spent to you, but you're not everyone.

There's no "right" answer here, only a spectrum of options that are better or worse depending on your personal preferences and the kinds of activities you undertake.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by oftenwrong on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @10:30AM (#6888047)
I think you proved their point. An $11k premium in addition to lower gas mileage.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by dllthomas on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:39PM (#6884342)
"It's not even the monetary cost of renting, it's the time cost."

Absolutely. I'd definitely meant for that to be a part of "overhead" but it probably is worth calling out explicitly.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by tdees40 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:02PM (#6884848)
For most hauling cases, you can rent a truck/van from Home Depot for $20/hour or so. It takes about five minutes to do. Obviously that isn't everyone's use case, but Enterprise will pick you up, or Zip Car or even cabs is a valid possibility. None of these are all that difficult.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by msandford on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @08:24PM (#6885288)
Not difficult on an absolute scale, but definitely more difficult than getting your keys, going out into the driveway and driving off.

So it depends on how frequently you use a truck as an input into the cost of owning vs cost of renting equation. At once per year it absolutely makes sense to rent. At once per day it absolutely makes sense to own. Many use cases fall in between.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by dllthomas on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:57PM (#6885163)
Like I said, it's been falling. Transportation to/from Home Depot is time and expense. Enterprise will pick you up, but there's slop in when exactly that will be, and it still doesn't entirely remove the time to/from the rental car place. The nearest ZipCar isn't always available. And nonetheless, these might be fantastic options for most people. My only points were that overhead shouldn't be overlooked, but that it's been falling. If you look at it and determine that, for your situation, it's less, then great! That will be the case in an increasing number of situations; I make no claim at all about how many or few.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by dionidium on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:15PM (#6884173)
Everybody knows this is true, of course. I live three miles from work. To get here this morning I could have walked 3 blocks to the light rail station near my apartment, then another 4 or so blocks from the destination station to my office. This is pretty convenient, especially in St. Louis, where the vast, vast majority of residents don't have options nearly that good.

But I didn't do it. It was 16F degrees when I left the house this morning. I drove my car.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by dionidium on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:29PM (#6884279)
I'll add that I'm a supporter of our transit system. I moved to my current apartment in part to be near it (and it plays a role in deciding where I'd like to work). But even after configuring my life about as much as is possible in this city to make the train an option, the car is still very often the most convenient, hassle-free option.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by eru on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:07PM (#6885855)
Put on some proper clothing and take your bike?
Re:Cars Kill Cities by dded on Friday December 13, 2013 @03:00PM (#6902576)
Perhaps you're being facetious, but on the off change that you're just not familiar with 16F (-9C), understand that that's cold. I'm a runner, but I don't go out if it's below 20F--I can't take it no matter what I wear. And a given temperature feels much colder on a bike.

Of course, if it's 16F, there's likely some ice and snow about, and riding a bicycle is treacherous in that. And St. Louis is on the eastern edge of the central time zone, so it'll be pitch dark out when he gets off work, also treacherous given traffic.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by jchrisa on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:54PM (#6889233)
I'm carfree in Portland Oregon and I LOVE biking in the icy mornings. What a great way to wake up.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by droob on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @06:16PM (#6884598)
Ha! I was going to write almost this exact post -- I can travel from Maplewood to Washington Ave every day by bus in about an hour, or by car in about half an hour.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by astrodust on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:57PM (#6884052)
> Cars are usually much faster, provide much better shelter from the weather...

If only there was such a thing as a car that you could call on-demand, make use of when you wanted it, and then got rid of it when you were done.

Even better, what about one that comes with a driver?

A crazy idea, I know.

If you live in the right neighborhood, a car is a nuisance. I can go somewhere and just walk right in. I don't have to spend time finding a parking spot, paying for parking, dealing with parking tickets, and all that related nuisance. Having owned a car, I found it shapes your decisions a lot. Things are only convenient if they're convenient to get to in a car.

Considering how much money I'm not spending on a car, a cab is a bargain. If I need more than that, rent a van by the hour.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by nilkn on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:11PM (#6884154)
The following page estimates the true cost of car ownership at approximately $1.38/mile: http://commutesolutions.org/external/calc.html

That's still quite a bit cheaper than taxi fares or the minimum $2.75 that Uber charges. Assuming that you spend $20k on purchasing the car, you'd make up for the cost of the car in just under 15,000 miles driven compared to taking Uber at the quoted rate.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by rayiner on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:20PM (#6884211)
I think the point is that you can live near transit and take advantage of cabs as needed and still come out ahead. When we lived in Chicago, my wife and I would take cabs all the time, especially on weekends or when the weather was bad. I think we spent maybe $100-200/month on cab fare. Now I have a car, and spend $150/month on insurance, $200+/month on parking, $300/month on gas. Averaged over the year, consumables (tires, brakes) and maintenance probably cost $100/month. And it's a paid off car, so I'm not even counting the car payment!
Re:Cars Kill Cities by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:17PM (#6884196)
Yeah, I don't really understand why people figure that self-driving cars/taxis/Uber/ZipCar would ever be cheaper per mile. They pay to operate their vehicles same as you do, except they also need to have some profit on top.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by tedsanders on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:22PM (#6884239)
High fixed costs and economies of scale.

Cars are high fixed cost capital goods. A taxi will be driven far more over the course of its lifetime than a personal car, so the fixed cost per mile is much lower.

Also, economies of scale make purchases and maintenance and repair cheaper.

These are two reasons to believe taxis should be cheaper than personal ownership.

Finally, let me point to airplanes. It makes far more sense to rent an airplane than buy one because almost no one travels enough to justify the purchase. Cars are analogous.

Edit: When I say cars are analogous, I mean that there are analogues between the situations. Both are vehicles with high fixed cost that can be either bought or rented. The situation is comparable, though obviously not the same. All I'm saying is that it's conceivable that someday the conditions could change so that it's more sensible to rent than buy.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:31PM (#6884286)
These are two reasons to believe taxis should be cheaper than personal ownership.

Well, could be. But the cabbie's wages quickly eat into those gains.

It makes far more sense to rent an airplane than buy one because almost no one travels enough to justify the purchase. Cars are analogous.

Hardly. A 737 lasts for decades and spends nearly a full half of that time in the air; of course no one flies that much. Cars on the other hand, if driven slightly over the US average- say, 20,000miles/year- will hit 200,000 miles in just 10 years, and most cars are _done_ by 200k.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:40PM (#6884362)
There are some interesting value engineering issues where car parts are designed to fall apart more or less simultaneously at a certain point under normal commuter operating conditions, whereas aircraft are designed to last "forever" more or less.

Its going to be a very strange maintenance challenge. I suspect one will never be totaled by having the heater core rot out after 16 years, like my last car.

You could probably find a car value engineered for long distance taxi/commercial type service. I imagine it would be somewhat different than a normal car, internally, although I don't know enough automotive engineering to tell exactly how.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:44PM (#6884386)
I imagine it would be somewhat different than a normal car

Usually beefier in every regard, more expensive, and less performant. (Power/MPG/etc all directly conflict with durability/longevity) Longer chassis & softer suspension to reduce vibration & impacts. Just think of the Crown Vic. There's a reason it has been the commercial estate car for so long.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by randuser on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:38PM (#6885055)
Didn't Ford cancel the Crown Victoria line?
Re:Cars Kill Cities by ars_technician on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:26PM (#6884263)
>Cars are analogous.

No they aren't. Many people need a car every day. Almost nobody needs a plane every day.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by astrodust on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:49PM (#6884418)
Most people are in a situation where they're forced to use a car every day. This situation could be resolved through smarter planning, better urban design, and alternative methods of transportation.

Two hundred years ago nobody needed a car because it didn't exist. Now people need it because parts of society are so entangled with it that it's nearly impossible to pull them apart.

If somehow planes had wrangled their way into our lifestyle the same way, then yes, people would need a plane every day. How else would they get home to their chalet in an inaccessible part the woods six hundred miles from the office at the end of a work-day?

Re:Cars Kill Cities by tedsanders on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:47PM (#6884404)
I don't want to argue pointlessly, but while your conclusion may be right, I think your logic makes some leaps. Why is day the natural time scale? No one needs a plane every hour and no one needs a car every hour either. By that time scale, they are the same. Also, everyone needs a plane every year and needs a car every year too. On that time scale they are also the same. Only in a cherry-picked intermediate time scale are they different. :) I think your answer would be improved if you could justify why the daily time scale is most relevant.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by anthonyb on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:04PM (#6884856)
You are being overly pedantic. Try s/every day/frequently/g and see how you go...
Re:Cars Kill Cities by tedsanders on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:24PM (#6884970)
Pardon me, but what is s/g?
Re:Cars Kill Cities by htp on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:45PM (#6885097)
"s/every day/frequently/g” is a UNIX-y way of saying “substitute ‘frequently’ in place of ‘every day’ in the entire document”.

(See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sed#Substitution .)

Re:Cars Kill Cities by tedsanders on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:17PM (#6885669)
Thanks!
Re:Cars Kill Cities by ars_technician on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:16PM (#6885450)
The time scale in fact can go the other direction and still favor cars. It's about cost per use.

If you drive every day like many Americans, it's cheaper to own a car than to use a cab. The number of people that fly enough to need their own plane is effectively zero.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by astrodust on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:47PM (#6884401)
What if you only travel maybe fifty miles by car per month?

If you don't have a car all the time, you don't use it nearly as often. I do not spend anywhere near $20K per year on cab fare, and can't imagine coming even close.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by genwin on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:36PM (#6884315)
The indirect auto costs are paid by everyone (and pollution is attributable to the bus riders as well), so it gives an incentive to own a cheap reliable car that isn't depreciating much. If I take my kid to someplace 1 mile away it's $3.75 and 15 minutes by bus, or ~$0.80 and 5 minutes by car. I do prefer to walk if it's only a mile.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by was_hellbanned on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:42PM (#6884371)
I'm an avid cyclist and motorcyclist. I've gone skydiving and SCUBA diving. Yet some of the most frightening moments in my life have been in the back of San Francisco taxis.

The sooner robots replace taxi drivers, the better. And the taxis will probably still feel gross inside.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by secabeen on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:21PM (#6884951)
That's the thing that worries me about self-driving taxis replacing my car. Taxis are relatively gross and designed to be easy to clean. I don't see shared vehicles having the comfort of a privately-owned vehicle.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by phaer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:20PM (#6884218)
Cars are convenient for an individual, but that is because you do out-source most of the negative aspects of them to the society around you. Just image how green, quiet and open streets (the space between buildings) could be without cars or with cars which deliver goods only, especially in bigger cities. The air would be a lot better too, roads need a lot of maintenance, cars need a lot of fuel, create a lot of pollution etc
Re:Cars Kill Cities by ars_technician on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:23PM (#6884241)
How do you envision goods being delivered to people then?
Re:Cars Kill Cities by phaer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:39PM (#6884343)
As I wrote, I am open to keep delivery cars. Freight bicycles are also a good possibility for a lot's of stuff, but that's not my main point. My main point would be that cars do suck as a mean of transporting people as soon as you do calculate with external costs to the environment, health and quality of live for people living in the inner city.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:35PM (#6884314)
They would subsist merely on great clouds of smug, rainbow baths, meditation, and unicorn droppings. The rest of us, of course, will drive a car.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by phaer on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:42PM (#6884374)
Wow, wheres the argument? I guess you are a very rational, thoughtful person compared to naive hippies like me, so why don't you use your skills?
Re:Cars Kill Cities by VLM on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:53PM (#6884444)
OK I admit I didn't answer anything. They'd probably bum rides off their friends with cars, just like I did as a kid. Which doesn't scale and is very inconvenient and economically devastating.

There are some interesting real estate issues such that you'd essentially be implementing feudalism where a peasant comes with the land and cannot leave it for other employment. Or the parasitic FIRE sector would have to back off a bit so housing is more of a commodity. Either way isn't happening without much unhappiness.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by gress on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:29PM (#6885721)
Unicorns are GMOs and would never be permitted in the same city as rainbow baths.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by GuiA on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:42PM (#6883936)
Self driving electric cars that people pay for on a subscription model (rather than ownership) are the future I'd like to see. I hope it happens during my lifetime.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by lambda on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:11PM (#6884151)
Yep. I've used Zipcar in lieu of a car before (and now own a car that I use maybe once every two weeks), but there was just enough friction due to having to walk to the nearest available car (the closest location to us wasn't always available, so we'd have to walk a few blocks further for the closest available car), having to pay for the time when the car is just parked at your destination before you return it, and not being suitable for the kind of longer range, weekend or week long trips that are a lot of what we need a car for.

If the cars were self-driving, however, that would solve the majority of those problems. No need to hike to find the closest car, it would come to you. No need to pay for the time that it's parked while at your destination, it could be used by other people, and another car could come pick you up when you needed to leave. No need to return the car to where you picked it up, it would just go back to the closest available station and they'd rebalance themselves automatically.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by jowiar on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:44PM (#6883962)
Taxis are a reasonable "turking" of this concept.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by chriswarren on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:58PM (#6884067)
Taxis in general don't fully turk the concept, at least not in areas without reliable taxi volume. It's reasonable as long as you can rely on the taxi to show up within a decent amount of time of requesting it or expect to see one in passing in a short amount of time.

Uber et al. have done a lot to help with this in my experience, but I've had many times where I'm in a location that taxis aren't typically in the immediate vicinity. Calling the cab company has often led to lots of waiting, not knowing when the car will get there, with cars sometimes never showing up at all. Knowing that the car is definitely coming to you (whether it's a self driving car, Uber, or any other service that tracks the vehicle's location) help remove that uncertainty and definitely makes it an acceptable option in more areas.

That reliability and knowledge justify the extra cost for taking Uber (or requesting a self driving car some day) to me, more than the comfort or style of a town car compared to a cab.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by jowiar on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:53PM (#6892864)
Agreed on all parts - for me, I live in DC, in a neighborhood with good cab density, and Uber is in the cab business as well as the swanky car business. I'll launch the app, hail a cab, and by the time I ride down the elevator of my building, there's a cab parked out front waiting for me. It's a reasonable approximation of the future.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by lambda on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:19PM (#6884210)
Taxis are a lot more expensive than self-driving cars. The driver takes something like 60% of the fare you pay for a taxi; I'm sure insurance eats up another sizeable chunk, and if self-driving cars are ever allowed on the streets, they will have to be safer than human drivers, and thus will have lower insurance costs. Furthermore, eliminating the driver means that you could use even smaller, cheaper cars, or fit more people or belongings per car, making self-driving cars more efficient.

Taxis drivers also really frustrating to deal with (the majority in my city, at least); I can't count the number of taxi drivers who haven't been able to find my house, so I've had to play phone tag with dispatch while waiting 45 minutes for a cab that should have been there in 10, then finally hike down the hill, get in, and had them start the meter while they drove up it to pick up my belongings.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by ghaff on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:39PM (#6885525)
>Taxis are a lot more expensive than self-driving cars.

But they have the advantage of actually existing. Whatever relatively near-term possibilities there may be for cars to operate on "autopilot" on certain highways, an urban environment where taxis are most common is probably one of the last places you'll see self-driving cars.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by lambda on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:07PM (#6885856)
Sure. I'm just pointing out how these hypothetical self driving taxis/car shares would be a substantial improvement over actual taxis, enough so that they would be able to displace more than just the niche that taxis currently occupy but also car sharing programs like Zipcar and probably a substantial portion of car ownership.

I think that I'll see them in my lifetime; I don't know if it'll be in 5 years (though I think that would be pushing it), 10 years, or 30 years, but I'm pretty sure they will come about, and will be a huge improvement over our current system of letting distracted, impatient people try to pilot cars through chaotic conditions.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by GuiA on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:15PM (#6884180)
True; although one major problem is that for n taxis, you have to pay for n cars and n human salaries, and human salaries end up being the biggest proportion in the final price.

How much will the cost be reduced when we don't have to pay for human drivers anymore? Will we see 50$ a month (2013 dollars) plans for 50 hours of "chauffeuring"? (a quick google search shows that the average american spends ~40h driving a year)

Re:Cars Kill Cities by dllthomas on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @05:41PM (#6884367)
In some areas, rent to medallion holders might end up being the biggest proportion in the final price...
Re:Cars Kill Cities by lambda on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:44AM (#6886099)
According to [this resarch](http://www.schallerconsult.com/taxi/taxifb.pdf), 57% of the fare (including tip) goes to the driver, 24% to vehicle and gas, 15% to the owner, and 4% to other expenses.

So, the driver is a pretty substantial portion of that. Taking the driver out of the equation would substantially reduce the costs. If you increased medallion availability as well, and the owners were able to work with lower margins (or they were cooperatively owned), you could get the cost down even further, to maybe 1/3 of what taxis currently cost. That would be a huge difference in affordability for everyday use.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by dllthomas on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @08:52AM (#6887593)
Nice!

"That would be a huge difference in affordability for everyday use."

Very true.

Re:Cars Kill Cities by samolang on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:58PM (#6884063)
And zipcar.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by jowiar on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:56PM (#6892876)
Zipcar is great - I love it. But as far as a "self-driving car network" goes, one of the big advantages is that you don't need to worry about parking on either end. A higher percentage of cars are in the process of getting someone from point A to point B rather than taking up space somewhere.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by nitrogen on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:48PM (#6885570)
Subscriptions sure are convenient (and lucrative), but there's also something to be said for the certainty of an owned asset that will always be there, even if you run out of money later.
Re:Cars Kill Cities by seanmcdirmid on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @07:02PM (#6884844)
I lived the earlier part of my adult life with a car (15-30), and have now been car free for 8 years or so.

I live in a dense city where you have to win a lottery to buy a car. So I take a taxi most places, which is just as convenient and environmentally probably the same impact (sans the need for parking, taxis are nice in that way).

Our city also has great delivery services, which my wife takes advantage of. She ordered some stuff one morning on Taobao and they were delivered that afternoon, no quadrocopter drone necessary.

> It would be a lot easier to rely solely on public transport if you never had to carry anything.

Amen. American public transit advocates should start looking at this aspect: even if we get density to enable public transport, there are a bunch of other services that are necessary to make car-less practical (local grocery stores, deliveries, etc...)

Re:Cars Kill Cities by Shivetya on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @04:43PM (#6883956)
when electric cars, or alternative fuels, become more prevalent and we have the ability for self driving cars the effect will become even more pronounced.

With self driving cars and dedicated roads or lanes for them; we already have special toll lanes in many cities; the distance one lives from work may become a non factor. Throw in better tools for telework and cities may simply become the home to two groups, those who can afford their secure enclaves and those trapped by government subsidies.

Cars gave freedom to many people, freedom to move about as they want, freedom to shop where they want, and freedom to live where they want and still do work. Automation will increase all of those options. Cities will need to reinvent themselves to be relevant.