I thought Logo was dumb and could never get into it, but one day after school in grade 6 I saw my friend had used Logo to open a command prompt on a school computer. He had gone into QBASIC and made a rocket ship fly using just print commands.
I was hooked instantly. I spent most of my non-school waking hours for the next few months coding in BASIC, entering programs from books I found buried in the library, and pouring through the help system to learn how to do new things.
Programming then really taught me to dig deep and figure things out on my own using resources available to me, and gave me a source of pride and confidence that I didn't get from other avenues. Eventually earning a great sense of accomplishment as I'd teach friends how to use various game engines that I'd develop at home.
Without that first experience in elementary school -- ultimately enabled through a feature of Logo -- I'd never have begun that journey.
School is there to show kids how to teach themselves anything they want to learn. Not to spoonfeed them specific skills they may or may not want to have.
It should include a bunch of basic skills as well - because seriously, I'd rather be taught "here's the common, most successful way of doing X" rather than having to go out and discover it on my own for thousands of random skills. Does that mean one day I may have to give up my notion of "checkbook register" that is comfortable and I've known forever in favor of "proper double entry book keeping" - absolutely, and you know what, I'll take a class on that too. But in the mean time, I won't be figuring out how to track my dollars on my own, and in the future I won't rediscover double entry for myself. Why?
I'm too busy focusing on software stuff in depth. That's where I'm focusing my "learn for myself" talents and limited time.
>Isn't that the best way?
Best for what? Best for being a good programmer? In my experience, no. You can't avoid spending 1000s of hours outside of school programming and reading about programming, but having fantastic teachers to help guide you through that journey is awesome when you can get it.
>School is there to show kids how to teach themselves anything they want to learn.
Not any school that I want my kids in. I want my kids in the school that teaches them how to read, add, and understand the science of the world around them - including how their stupid cellphone works. They've got the rest of their day and the rest of their lives (with a bit of latitude starting in the last half of high school, and college) to learn whatever they want, at least until all the libraries are closed and everything is behind a paywall.
Eh, debatable. I'd tend to say that ideally school is there to give kids experience with a wide range of activities and to try to inspire in them a love of learning in at least one of them, as well as the basic methodologies of doing so.
I don't think spoon-feeding, or making people learn skills they blatantly don't like, has great returns. But I wouldn't go quite so far as saying school's just there to show them how to learn - considering how directed the learning environment is, school doesn't really seem to spend much time on that at all.
There are things that did teach me "how to learn" but they only arose outside of school and after high school. There are things that have given me a fearless desire to learn, and the confidence to know that there's nothing I can't come to understand if I am willing to apply myself. However, none of those things happened inside of the traditional school system.
Programming is only one skill that people are afraid to learn, there are thousands of others and we can't have elementary school classes for them all.
>we can't have elementary school classes for them all.
We not only can have elementary school classes for it, we do, and have since I first walked into one 32 years ago. That fact is responsible for a large percentage of the programmers walking around today.
>we need to address the current holes in our education system before we start adding new course work
In my opinion, weakness in math (and programming) is one of the current holes in our education system. I'm also trying to argue that this is not new coursework.
I think we look at computer programming much differently in terms of our world view and should probably leave it at that. Thanks for making some great comments and being a cool person.
Confidence that I could program came from being exposed to programming on Apple IIs and the Casio FX-702P. Being taught some simple graphing with BASIC in class laid the groundwork. Later came watching others create things, then trying out my own ideas in BASIC, failing, and then trying again.
This should be applied to other important fields as well -- for example a medical-themed biology class I took as a kid helped me understand that being a doctor was attainable (but not for me).
I don't understand this post at all. There were programming classes at elementary school 25-30 years ago teaching Logo and Basic on Apple IIs. If it weren't for those classes, I can't really be sure that I'd be programming now.
So we shouldn't have programming classes for children now because confidence? Am I missing something, or does confidence often come with experience, especially experience gained in childhood when you're too young and stupid to be properly terrified?
If you want to raise adult mountain climbers, does it make sense to start your children climbing hills, or to spend their childhoods giving them the confidence to attempt to climb mountains as adults, oblivious to their own incompetence? I don't think confidence-building to the exclusion of skill-building is the way to go.