News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Doom’s Creator Looks Back on 20 Years of Demonic Mayhem by Bamafan on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:55AM (#6881382)
After reading this book, I realized I had WAAY underestimated Romero's impact on iD.

Point blank - without Romero, there is iD Software (it was his idea to form a new company). There is no Doom. There is no Quake. Romero was one of the primary creative forces behind iD.

Carmack was the tech genius who made their ideas come to life.

Re:Doom’s Creator Looks Back on 20 Years of Demonic Mayhem by talmand on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:56AM (#6881800)
I've not read the book, but I've often wondered if things would have been that different without Romero.

Maybe in the beginning he was a driving force but I speculate something changed. Be it something with him, technology changes, or whatever but he later did not seem to have as big an impact.

I met Romero back during the beginning of the Ion Storm days and based on that short chat with him I was convinced that Ion Storm would succeed. Sadly it did not. Granted, Ion Storm did turn out some of the best games ever made but not the one that Romero made.

Re:Doom’s Creator Looks Back on 20 Years of Demonic Mayhem by CaptainZapp on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @12:07PM (#6881893)
I think it's exactly this, which makes the comparison to Lennon / McCartney so apt.

Even as readers of the book learn that they are rather compared to Metallica.

I agree that it needed the two Johns to make iD happen.

On a sidenote: To me John Carmack is one of the true hacker heroes. That's for his almost militant stance aganst patents and for his generousity in sharing his code.