News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reform Government Surveillance by thaumasiotes on Monday December 09, 2013 @12:47AM (#6872979)
I kind of like it. It's a nice blow to the straw viewpoint that corporations should have no rights to speak.

Everything these companies say is informed by discussion in the media, among the public, and, yes, with elected officials. The line you want to draw is extremely fuzzy at best in reality.

I have read that Genghis Khan's original plan after conquering China was to raze the farming villages to provide more pasture for horses (and the Mongols that horse populations supported). Some bureaucrats pointed out to him that he could personally do better by taxing the Chinese farmers. And he sold out the Mongols to do it, which worked out great for him and the millions of peasants he didn't kill.

Do we count that as action by the peasants, who held essentially zero formal power, or by the mandarins, who could never have afforded to pay for the deal themselves?

Re:Reform Government Surveillance by 001sky on Monday December 09, 2013 @01:44AM (#6873119)
the straw viewpoint that corporations should have no rights to speak

But the CEO's also have a moral obligation to lead. Frankly, they have this obligation even if its not in the financial (narrow) interest of their company. Although what we are clearly seeing here is the 'existential' threat not only to their business models, but that <history> will view them as compllicit in a bad thing, imho.