Ask HN: Installing Linux on my router -- OpenWrt, X-Wrt, or Gargoyle?
My SMC WBR14T-G wireless 4-port router has been hanging a lot recently. If I unplug the power and plug it back in, it works again, but it's now happening multiple times per day. I've got the latest firmware. And I've had this trouble with previous (cheap) routers.
So I'm keen to buy a Linksys WRT54GL (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linksys_WRT54G_series) and install an OpenWrt-based Linux on it. I've read lots of good things about how this setup is very stable and configurable.
Anyway, I'm a programmer and okay at network stuff, but not an expert. I can certainly use config files, but I'd definitely prefer a good web interface.
Any suggestions? So far Gargoyle looks really nice, but a bit new/unproven yet. X-Wrt might be the way to go. Or plain OpenWrt?
(
13 comments
| 11 points
| on HN
)
http://lifehacker.com/344765/turn-your-60-router-into-a-user...
Having had an Airport for a little while, though, I don't know why neither of those were on your list—whether they were overlooked or whether they're outdated.
I didn't know the Apple AirPort was a "standard" wireless router. Cool. Now bidding on one... :-) http://www.trademe.co.nz/Browse/Listing.aspx?id=226933642
Not true. Most Linksys 54G routers run VxWorks. Only versions 1-4 of the WRT54G series ran Linux. There are many Linksys Draft N routers that run chipsets that are not compatible with any Linux firmware, but meny are Broadcom based and are therefore compatible. Not sure what OS Cisco is using for those.
Regardless, countless of us have found that even the Linux-based Linksys firmwares are garbage. Put Tomato or DD-WRT on one of them, however, and they run like a champ.
The most important added features would be a full blown Linux system. So basically do whatever you want on it(within the memory and processing available). In Open-WRT for example, you can add a number of packages and upgrade your system similarly to a GNU/Linux distro.