News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hundreds of Start-Ups Hope to Be a Copycat Start-Up by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 07, 2013 @12:41PM (#6866975)
The author confuses the language of '<this> for <that>' with a copy of. If you are the 'Uber of Dog Walking' you are not a copy of Uber. Instead you have taken one part of the Uber puzzle, "on demand access using a smart phone" and applied it to the problem of finding a dog walker [1]. The sort of language arises because these techniques and technologies are created without names.

In the physical world, you might have something like a gas turbine engine, which enabled the jet age. People put the same engine on helicopters. But they didn't say "These are the jets of vertical flight". Or when they used them as engines to generate electricity they didn't say "These are Jets for Power Plants." But the reason they didn't say those things is that it was pretty clear to everyone what a gas turbine engine was and what it brought to the table. Modern software startups don't have that luxury.

Of course there are a lot of me too like startups. Just like there are me too type bands and me too type serial killers. There is a segment of the population who sees an idea in action and then runs out and tries to do the same thing. But I don't think the industry is dominated by that mentality. Mostly because it is rarely successful if it is just a copy.

[1] I make no claim on whether or not finding Dog Walkers on demand is a good idea or a bad idea.

Re:Hundreds of Start-Ups Hope to Be a Copycat Start-Up by yajoe on Saturday December 07, 2013 @01:21PM (#6867098)
Like you, I place little weight on the findings from a few keyword searches. Such vacuous analysis.

That said, there are a few incentives in play for the "X for Y" or "<this> for <that>" language and why to use it over more simple, implementation-free descriptive text:

1. Newly-entered startups: Your wonderful description about why it is more efficient. See above :)

2. <this> companies (the Ubers and AirBnBs): Having other people constantly repeat the Uber and AirBnB label is brand advertising. Period. The Uber and AirBnB brands have good penetration in the HN demographic, but they are unknown to >50% of the US and >70% of the world. Those companies need advertising to fuel growth, so they have an incentive to encourage this practice since it's free for them AND a lot of startups are getting press in the midwest, etc.

3. <this> Stakeholders (investors, accelerators, etc): Moreover, using <this> in the context of another upstart business suggests that <this> was successful. When you say Uber for pizza, you are suggesting that Uber is both a successful model and a successful business. That makes both Uber and Uber's Stakeholders look really good. It's a form of social proof, which is especially valuable in this boom.

And remember, the Stakeholders eventually make their money in an IPO and not from direct profits. These Stakeholders have a strong incentive to convince others that <this> is a good business and worth mimicking in another market. "Look at all the others who followed suit." The Stakeholders need more fundraising rounds. And at a place like YC, you'll hear how it's a good idea because when you go looking to find the <this> that matches you, you're more likely to pick a <this> from here.

And at the end of the day, using "X for Y" is co-branding ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Co-branding ). It is a tool that has positive and negative aspects. In some places saying you are "Uber for pizza" means you are willing to skirt local health codes to deliver pizza faster than it takes to cook...

My advice is to recognize the "<this> for <that>" as a derivative of co-branding, and to understand the incentives in play for the advice on how to use it.

Re:Hundreds of Start-Ups Hope to Be a Copycat Start-Up by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 07, 2013 @03:23PM (#6867538)
I like your analysis of the incentives to do it, it reminded me that there is another place where it is used, Entertainment. Projects are pitched as "this is the Rambo for Millenials" or "This is Bonanza in Space."

So in those cases there is an attempt to transfer some of the success 'aura' of the brand name to the pitched project. No one pitches a movie saying its like "Heaven's Gate" :-) and I suppose nobody pitches a startup as "The Color for Dog Walkers."

Re:Hundreds of Start-Ups Hope to Be a Copycat Start-Up by 001sky on Saturday December 07, 2013 @02:15PM (#6867281)
I agree with the general thrust of this. In the specific context of startups, its also not so much mimicry as it is appropriation of the brand identity of (X,Y). Its basically leveraging others expenditures as a form of budget "hack", because its both quicker and less resource intensive. As a result, as a guerilla (marketing) tactic its effective. It also PR/link bait for lazy journalists. Their audiences are usually already conditioned on the uber awesomeness of X and/or Y. Last but not least, is a sort of pavlovian effect on investors's greed instinct.

edits: brevity

Re:Hundreds of Start-Ups Hope to Be a Copycat Start-Up by tomblomfield on Saturday December 07, 2013 @01:54PM (#6867204)
Spot-on. This article misses the point entirely - X for Y is just a convenient (if somewhat lazy) way of describing new concepts by reference to existing ones.

I was hoping that the author would really dig into the practice of startup clones - c.f. http://www.rocket-internet.de