I think the latter is naive. I think bitcoin is the first currency whose perpetual deflation is ensured by the contract that defines it.
While I think that bitcoin will recover, perpetual deflation is not guaranteed. Indeed, in general deflation of bitcoin depends on an increase in demand that outstrips the increase in supply.
A full disclosure of my bitcoin history: I bought in at 150 and cashed out at 300 because I got cold feet and I needed the money - I'd have held on if I didn't need the money. I forgot that I had an autodraw, which kept buying at the 300-ish mark, which I sold off at 900, again because I got cold feet about my 1200 mark and I needed the money. This hasn't been entirely speculative work, I have used bitcoin in 'actual bitcoin' transaction. But not silk road.
The nonprofit that I am launching on tuesday will be accepting bitcoin donations starting on friday.
Bitcoin is based on the idea that money gets its intrinsic value from its scarcity, which is a misconception since money gets its intrinsic value from the volume of transactions involving goods and services that use it
No, bitcoin is based on the idea that money gets its intrinsic value from its trust model. That's why it has advanced crypto-mathematics to establish verifability, and so forth. Now. Bitcoin promoters think that the scarcity can drive the value up to the point where it becomes widely adopted. Criticism of this model to spur adoption may be totally fair.