Re:The Prisoners’ Paradox
by devin on Friday July 03, 2009 @01:17PM
(#686334)
Forgive me, but doesn't it seem odd that the problem defines Prisoner A from one perspective, and Prisoner B from another?
Prisoner B could just as well be Prisoner A since A was defined by the narrator, and Prisoner B by the guard. I know we're descending into the theoretical stuff, probabilities and so on, but might there not even be enough information to go down any path at all given this dilemma?
Re:The Prisoners’ Paradox
by devin on Sunday July 05, 2009 @10:37PM
(#689028)
Really? From whose perspective is Prisoner A described as asking the question? The narrator's. Please correct me if I'm wrong, but there is an implicit third person in my view.
Prisoner B could just as well be Prisoner A since A was defined by the narrator, and Prisoner B by the guard. I know we're descending into the theoretical stuff, probabilities and so on, but might there not even be enough information to go down any path at all given this dilemma?