I think you've got it backwards. Only one is pardoned. His chance of survival is 1 in 3.
Re:The Prisoners’ Paradox
by randomtask on Friday July 03, 2009 @09:39AM
(#686014)
The initial chance of survival, after hearing that there is a chance, (for Prisoner A) is 1/3, since any one prisoner dies out of three. If he now knows, after consulting with the guard, that Prisoner B is sure to die that means that it's death for either A or C. Hence the chance of survival (and death since P(Death) = 1 - P(Survival)) is now 0.5. This results in a smaller chance of death (for him) 1/2 rather than 2/3. Hence the rejoicing.
Re:The Prisoners’ Paradox
by gambling8nt on Friday July 03, 2009 @09:50AM
(#686025)
Because of the way the information was gathered, the chances of survival for A and C are no longer equal (C is twice as likely to survive)--having only two possible outcomes does not guarantee that the probability is 50-50.
Prisoner A rejoices that his own chance of survival has improved from 1/3 to 1/2. But how is this possible? The guard has given him no new information. Has he?
No, Prisoner A still has a 1 in 3 chance of [edit: not] dieing. If he asked if Prisoner B had a pardon then you could argue his odds became 1/2. But, now he still only knows that at least one of his cellmates is going to die.