The argument I'm making is not that Windows is secure (because it isn't), but that Open Source isn't necessarily secure just because it's open source.
Open source is however possible to independent verify if it is secure. Closed source is not possible to verify as secure and must be taken solely on the word of the company who made it.
How many examples can you come up with? Was this specific bug being actively exploited when it was discovered?
A bug caused by prettying the code, which was secure from upstream, which is in an important, widely used, supposedly secure bit of code isn't a good enough example?
> Was this specific bug being actively exploited when it was discovered?
Many Linuxes used to ship with lots of services running. That lead to many rooted boxes being used to deliver spam. Open Source fixed the problem, but only after many millions of emails had been delivered.
Someone somewhere probably has a nice chart of all the Red Hat boxes in SKorea in the late 1990s early 2000s.
Again, this isn't to suggest that MS or Apple are more secure. For years anyone putting an MS server onto the Internet ran the risk of very quick exploitation.
It's a good example. Can you come up with more? Because, you know, it's just one instance of a problem. It says nothing on how pervasive it is.
> For years anyone putting an MS server onto the Internet ran the risk of very quick exploitation.
IIRC, there was a time when the average time between install and first invasion was in the 40 seconds range.
Debian SSL bug lasted 2 years. Open source means little for security.